ࡱ> XZSTUVW R8bjbj77'v]kv]kfB< < ==Tit|('h ($1(B`E()'|'E(E(==$ 6pppE(4=RpE(pp !" E\Bb{L0|#m&E(E(pE(E(E(E(E(nE(E(E(|E(E(E(E(E(E(E(E(E(E(E(E(E(< : B##H22#I'I2-4*#0 9I@*- Ms. JIAYING WANG -22#"L5H#6)22#I'I2-4*#0 +%1*9# #8(2*#!+214 Dr. Poramet Klinhom *22'4 2 2##4+2#2#(6)2 52#(6)2 2568  +1'I-2#I'I2-4*#0 2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9CB#@#5"!1"!(6)2C# 2 8 !%5K+%4 Promoting Teacher Professional Development in Secondary Schools in Changchun City, Jilin Province B##H22#I'I2-4*#05I@G*H'+6H-2#(6)2+%1*9##8(2*#!+214 *22'4 22##4+2#2#(6)2 !+2'4"2%1"#2  12 8#5 52#(6)2 2568 B##H22#I'I2-4*#0 9I@*- Ms. JIAYING WANG -22#"L5H#6)22#I'I2-4*#0 +%1*9# #8(2*#!+214 Dr. Poramet Klinhom *22'4 2 2##4+2#2#(6)2 52#(6)2 2568 _____________________________________________________________ +1'I-2#I'I2-4*#0 2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9CB#@#5"!1"!(6)2C# 2 8 !%5K+%4 Promoting Teacher Professional Development in Secondary Schools in Changchun City, Jilin Province B##H22#I'I2-4*#05I@G*H'+6H-2#(6)2+%1*9##8(2*#!+214 *22'4 22##4+2#2#(6)2 !+2'4"2%1"#2  12 8#5 52#(6)2 2568 vU_ ! *2#1  hvU_ ! *2#1 2#2 VvU_ ! *2#1  2 5H 1 3 '2!@G!2A%0'2!*31 -1 +2 '2!@G!2A%0'2!*31 -2#'41" C#0@(5#0@G5H@5H"'I-12#12'4 2 5#9DI#1'2!*C@4H!6I-"H2H-@7H-'9HD12#122#(6)21I7I2B"!54(2B"2"5HAH21DCAH%0 H'#0'14(2*#L11IAH2#H-1I*22##1#0 2 52#123%1#9DI@%5H"22#@I2#"2"3'D*9H2#C+I'2!*31 12#"#018 2C H'A#-2#122#(6)21I7I2 2#4+%17-2#AID1 +22#2A%#9A%02#(6)2#9#'!62#6-#!!8H@I@5"2#-*-'2!I-2#I22#*-C15-"H2D#G2!@!7H-*1!A%0@(#)412A%02#@I262#(6)2"2"1'2#6H2@5"2#@4H!3'#9D!H@5"-5H0#-#12#128 22#(6)21I7I2-"H2H-@7H-I'"@+85I2#12'4 2 5#96H-"F%2"@G#0@G*31 -2#4#92#(6)2A%0#0'2#122#(6)2*9H'2!1*!1" 1IAHI('##)5H21@GI!2@-*2#B"2"#01 24+%2" 1@ H+!2"'H2I'"#9A4142#7I92#(6)2#9A%0B"2"@5H"'12#(6)2H-@7H-*3+#1#9#01#0!(6)2A%0!1"!(6)2DI@I"I3-"H2 1@6@I2+!2"C2#*#I23%1#95H!58 2*9A%0!5'2!@G'4 2 5B"2"@+%H25IC+I'2!*31 12#*H@*#4!2#@4B2'4 2 5-#9H2A'25H@G#0A%0!52#1'2@ 4*21A'BI!B"2"5I*0I-62#@%5H"A%A'42#12#9-52A'25H@I 2#6-#! D*9HA'25H@I 2#12'4 2 5 3C+I2#12'4 2 5#9@%5H"2I-3+I22#6-#!@G#1I#2'D*9H2#@G-L#0-+%1-#02#319A%I22#(6)2 -"H2D#G2!2!8!!--2#3B"2"D414A%02#414C#01B#@#5"2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9CB#@#5"!1"!(6)2"1@ 4 '2!I22"+%2"#02#CI2+6H4##!2#12'4 2 5+%2"#9A"1!5%1)0 I3 I-A%0#01#02"CI22#--A@7I-+2A%0#9A2#14##!3C+I"2H-2#-*-'2!I-2#125HAI#4-#9C#42#*-@ 20-5I2+6H'2!AH2I2#0"0@'%22#4142#0"0122#C*2"-2 5A%0@7H-D-L#-B#@#5"*H%C+I#9A2#*1*82#12'4 2 5A@5"'1C+I%%1L5HD!H*!H3@*!-1 +2@+%H25I31#0*44%B"#'!-B"2"2#12#9A%0*0I-6'2!3@GC2#3'41"@ 4#01)L5H1I-"9H#4- 9!4 2A%0B#@#5"@ 20 C#012#(6)2!1"!(6)2'2!I22"5H@5H"'I-12#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9#2 1@@G4@()C#01 9!4 2C H'D!H5H55HH2!2!%5K+%4DIC+I'2!*31 -"H2!212#@*#4!*#I23%1#9B"3+C+I2#12'4 2 5#9@G%D*31 C2#"#018 22#(6)21I7I2C#01!%!52#--B"2"3'!25H@5H"'I-12#(6)2H-@7H--#92#12#06-#!#9A%02#"#01*!##02'4 2 5 6HH-"F@%5H"A'42#12#922# AIDI-#H- D*9H2# "#018 2 2"CIA'2B"2"1%H2'#-@ 4*21-2#12'4 2 5#9CB#@#5"!1"!(6)21H'1I!%DI#12#12-"H2H-@7H-3C+I#9!5B-2*@I2#H'!4##!2#6-#!A%02#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5!26IA%0(1" 22'4 2 5B"#'!DI#12#"#01 C20(9"L%2*31 I22#(6)21I7I2-!%5K+%4# 2 8DI3@42#2!B"2"2#12#9#01!%-"H2#41#I-!1I#4@#4H!!2#2#5H*-%I-1* 2I-4HC2414 2 8DIH-"F*#I2#02#*1*82#12'4 2 5C#01B#@#5"H22##1#8%D2#6-#!#92#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5CB#@#5"A%02#@*#4!*#I2 8! 2#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5B"#'!A%I'B#2#12'4 2 5*3+#1#9!1"!(6)2DI##%8%2#02#CI2+%1#01@ 4*21A%02#3@42@ 4-L# 6H@G7I2*31 C2#"#018 22#(6)2-B#@#5" -"H2D#G2!CI2%%1L-2#3@42#4#01-2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9CB#@#5"!1"!(6)2- 2 8"1AH21#0+'H2B#@#5"A%0%8H!#9H2FCI2+6H#9!1"!(6)2!1!5 2#02*-+1A%0I-@ 4 A#122#4#9+%1*9#-"H2H-@7H-#'!6'2!I-2#125H+%2+%2"-1@#5" 6H31@'%2A%0%125H*2!2#8H!@C+I12#12'4 2 5-5I2+6H'2!AH2I22B#@#5"2#1*###1"2#A%0A'22##4+2##'!6'2!I-2#2'4 2 55HAH21CAH%0 H'-2 5-#93C+I!2#2#*1*82#12'4 2 5A!2#2!1D!H*2!2#-*-'2!I-2#5H+%2+%2"DI-"H2@5"-*22#L5I*H%H-#0*44%B"#'!-2#3@42I22#12'4 2 5A%0H-C+I@42##1#9I5H 1 I-A%0AH21-#9H-2#*1*82#12'4 2 5C#01B#@#5" I'"@+85I6!5'2!3@GI-3@42#(6)2'41"-"H2@G#0@5H"'1#012#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9 2"CI#42#(6)2@ 20-!%5K+%4A%0# 2 82!8!!-2##1#9I-#92#(6)21%H2'*2!2#'4@#20+L#01B"#'!A%0'2!AH2-2#*1*82#12'4 2 5 6H0 H'"C+I!5+%12@ 4#01)L*3+#12##1#8%D2#*1*82#12'4 2 5#9C#01 9!4 2 7I2-#4B"2"A%0* 2'2!@G#41%H2'+1'I--2#(6)25I@46I2'2!*C2'4 22#-9I'41"CI2$)52##4+2#2#(6)2A%0'2!*C-"H2H-@7H-H-2#414C#01!1"!(6)2@7H-22#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9%2"@G@*2+%1*31 C2#"#018 22#(6)21I7I232!*31 7-0#0@!42#*1*82#12'4 2 5C#4B#@#5"A%0 9!4 2@ 20DI-"H2D#C@ 4'4"2(2*#L-"H2D#G2!2'41"5H!5-"9H*H'C+ H!8H@I#01B"2"!+ 2+#7-2#1'2@ 4*21B"C+I'2!*CH-I2I-"H-2##1#9I#4-#9!1"!(6)25H4142-"9HH-2#*1*82#12'4 2 5C#4B#@#5"B"@ 202'41"@ 4#01)L5H#'*-'2!AH2#01 9!4 2-"H2@G#0"1!5-"9HI-" 11I2#(6)25I63+C+IB#@#5"!1"!(6)21H'DC# 2 8!%5K+%4@G#42#'41"A%0#9!1"!(6)25H4142-"9H@G%8H!1'-"H2H2A'2@ 4#01)L2#(6)25I!8H#'*-#01B"#'!-2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9B"311"I2#0"0@'%22#4142-#9A%02-B#@#5"!2'4@#20+L'2!AH2-2#*1*82#12'4 2 5C%8H!#9A%0@7H-D-L#5HAH21@7H-3'2!@I2C-"H2%6 6I"4H6I'H22#*1*82#12'4 2 53@42#-"H2D#C2414 CI2#0@5"'452#(6)25IC IA*-2!C2#@G#'#'!I-!9%A%0C I2#'4@#20+L2*44C2##0@!4#012#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9CB#@#5"!1"!(6)2#-2##0@!49*#I26IC+%2"!44DIAH2#*1*82B#@#5"B-2*C2#6-#!A%02#@#5"#9I2'4 2 52#12'4 2 5C#01B#@#5"A%02#*1*82#12@--#92!8!!--#92#(6)25I!8H3@*- 2#'!5H#-%8!-2#*1*82#12'4 2 5C#01B#@#5"%2#'41"2'H20@GI-!9%@ 4#01)L*3+#12##1#8%D2#*1*82#12'4 2 5C#01 9!4 2A%0@G+%12@ 4#5(6)25H@G#9##!C2'41"I22##4+2#2#(6)2 2#(6)25I!51I'2!*31 C@ 4414A%0@ 4$)5C@ 4414H22#*3#'A*-2!A%02#'4@#20+L2*442#(6)25I3@*- 2#'!-2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9C+!9H#9!1"!(6)2C# 2 8!%5K+%4#'!6'2!AH22!#01#0*2#L2#*-A%02-B#@#5"2%2#'41"*2!2##081 +2#H'!A%0#9A'2!AH2-2#*1*82#12'4 2 5 6H@GI-!9%-I2-4*3+#1+H'"2I22#(6)2C2#3+B"2"12#9A%0#1#8%D2#6-#!A%02#*1*8%2#'41""1*2!2# H'"C+I9I#4+2#B#@#5"!1"!(6)2#1%"8L2##4+2#2#12'4 2 5C#01B#@#5"C+I!5'2!@ 20@20A%0AH2!2"4H6I C@ 4$)52#(6)25I1I-"9H#4 9!4 2@ 20A%0C I!8!!-2##1#9I-#9C2#'4@#20+L@ 4#01)L@5H"'12#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9CB#@#5"!1"!(6)2 6H H'"@4H!92'41"@ 4#5(6)2#01 9!4 2C*222#12'4 2 5#9%2#'41"D!H@5"C+I+%12@ 4#01)L*3+#12##'*-'2!@+!20*!-$)5 H'-2 5-#9A%0$)5@7H-D-L#-B#@#5"C#42#(6)21I7I2@H21IAH"1C+IA'2-I2-4*3+#12#@%7-1'A#@#7H-!7-'41"A%0A'22#'4@#20+L@ 4#01)LC2'41"H-D-5I'" '18#0*L-2#'41" 1. @7H-(6)22#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9CB#@#5"!1"!(6)2C# 2 8 !%5K+%4 2. @7H-@#5"@5"2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9CB#@#5"!1"!(6)2C# 2 8 !%5K+%4 B"3A2!#0"0@'%22#4142-#9A%02-B#@#5" . *!!42-2#'41" 1.2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9CB#@#5"!1"!(6)2C# 2 8!%5K+%4!5'2!AH212!#0"0@'%22#4142-#9 2. 2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9CB#@#5"!1"!(6)2C# 2 8!%5K+%4!5'2!AH212!2-B#@#5" #-A'4C2#'41" 2#'41"#1I5I!8H@I2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9CB#@#5"!1"!(6)2C# 2 8 !%5K+%4 B"3 #0*2#L2#32-#9 (Work Experience) A%0 2B#@#5" (School Size) !2@G1'A#-4*#0 (Independent Variables) A%0C I #012#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9 @G1'A#2! (Dependent Variables) CI2#-$)5 2#'41"5I-2(1"#-A'42#12'4 2 5#9- Guskey (2002) C2#3+!44-1'A#2!--@G 4 I2 DIAH 1)2#12'2!#9I2'4 2 5 2)1)0A%02#4142'4 2 5 3)1(4A%0-1%1)L2'4 2 5 4)2#*1*8@ 4-L#A%0@ 4*21 #I-!1I-4 $)5 H'122#2'4 2 5 (Career Stage Theory) - Huberman (1989) A%0 Day (2017) @7H--42"2#C I#0*2#L2#32-#9@G1'A- H'122#2'4 2 5 A%0-4 $)52##4+2#2#(6)2 (Educational Management Theory) - Hoy & Miskel (2013) A%0 Bush (2011) @7H--42"2#C I2B#@#5"@G1'A#*0I-'2!AH2-#4-L#B#@#5" -25I 2#'41""1"6!8!!- 2##1#9I-#9 (Teacher Perception Perspective) @GA'2*31 C2#'4@#20+L B"@IC+I'2!*31 12##0@!4-#9H-2#*1*82#12'4 2 52B#@#5" B#*#I22#'41"6-"9HC%1)0  %1)02'4 2 5-#9A%0#4--L#B#@#5"  2##1#9I-#9  #012#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9 8*31 -2#'41"7-2#(6)2'H2 #95H!5#0*2#L2#32AH21 A%0#95H32CB#@#5"5H!52AH21 0!52##1#9IH-2#*1*82#12'4 2 52B#@#5"AH21-"H2D# A%0'2!AH21%H2'*0I---!2C#012#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9-"H2D# -@-2#'41" (Scope of the Research) 2!A'4-Guskey(2002)2#12'4 2 5#9(Teacher Professional Development:TPD)#0-I'"-L#0-*31 1H-D5I: 1.2#12'2!#9I2'4 2 5 1)B#@#5"1C+I!52#6-#!-"H2@G#0 2)2#*#I2-L#A+H2#@#5"#9I 3)2#!5A2#12'4 2 55H 1@2 2. 1)0A%02#4142'4 2 5 1) 2#12'4 2 5C#01B#@#5" 2)2#*1@2#*-'2!#H'!!7-#0+'H2#9A%02#'41"C 1I@#5" 3. 1(42'4 2 5A%0-1%1)L2'4 2 5 1) 2#*1*8A%02#"-!#129I#4+2#B#@#5" 2) %D2##0@!45H@G##! 3) @*I2'2!I2'+I2C*2"-2 55H 1@ 4.2#*1*8@ 4-L#A%0@ 4*21 1) '455H9I#4+2#2#(6)2--AB"2"2#12'4 2 5 2)2-A%-#L!441% #02##0@!4 A%0%D9C -@#0 2#A%0%8H!1'-"H2 #0 2#:#0 2#-2#(6)25I#0-I'"#9B#@#5"!1"!(6)2C# 2 8!%5K+%4#'!1I*4I475B"@ 20#0-I'"#93'952B#@#5"!1"!(6)2 2 8+!2"@%13'882B#@#5"!1"!(6)2%-!%5K+%43'752B#@#5"!1"!(6)2%- 2 84H'D3'702B#@#5"!1"!(6)2 2 8+"2@4I3'822B#@#5"!1"!(6)2C@#7-!+2'4"2%1"#9 20'1--@ 5"@+7-A%03'652B#@#5"!1"!(6)2 2 8@+'4%5H %8H!1'-"H2:%8H!1'-"H2#0-I'"#9B#@#5"!1"!(6)2C# 2 8!%5K+%43'210C52#(6)22025 20262%8H!1'-"H23+B"C I'452#*8H!-"H2H2"2!@L-KrejcieA%0Morgan(1970)B"@ 20#0-I'"#93'422B#@#5"!1"!(6)2 2 8+!2"@%13'392B#@#5"!1"!(6)2%-!%5K+%43'332B#@#5"!1"!(6)2%- 2 84H'D3'312B#@#5"!1"!(6)2 2 8+"2@4I3'362B#@#5"!1"!(6)2C@#7-!+2'4"2%1"#9 20'1--@ 5"@+7-A%03'292B#@#5"!1"!(6)2 2 8@+'4%5H 1'A#2#'41" C2#(6)25I1'A#2#'41"93+15I 1'A#-4*#07-%1)07I2-#9B#@#5"!1"!(6)23A2!#0"0@'%22#4142-#9A%02-B#@#5" #0"0@'%22#4142-#9AH--@G*-%8H!2!A'AH H'-2 55HDI1H'DC'####!I22#12#9(Huberman,1989;Day,2017): 1)#9 H'I6%2-2 5(!5#0*2#L1 155) 2)#95H!5#0*2#L*9(!5#0*2#L1656ID) 2-B#@#5"AH--@G*2!#0@ : 1)B#@#5"2@%G (#9 50 +#7-I-"'H2) 2)B#@#5"2%2 (#9 51 100 ) 3)B#@#5"2C+ H (#9 101 6ID) 1'A#2!-2#(6)25I7-#012#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9C+!9H#9B#@#5"!1"!(6)2C# 2 8!%5K+%4B"-I2-4#-2#12'4 2 5#9(TPD)-Guskey(2002)1'A#2!9'1H2*5H!44DIAH: 1) 2#12'2!#9I2'4 2 5 2) 1)0A%02#4142'4 2 5 3) 1(42'4 2 5A%0-1%1)L2'4 2 5 4) 2#*1*8@ 4-L#A%0@ 4*21 @#7H-!7-'41" @#7H-!7-'41"5HC IC2#(6)25I7-A*-2! 6H#0-I'"*-*H' *H'5H+6H!8H@II-!9%7I21H'D-9I-A*-2!B"3A2!#0"0@'%22#4142-#9A%02-B#@#5" *H'5H*-126I7I2#-2#12'4 2 5#9(TPD)-Guskey(2002)A%0!8H@I2D5H#9B#@#5"!1"!(6)2C# 2 8!%5K+%4*H'5I#0-I'"*5HI2DIAH: 1)2#12'2!#9I2'4 2 5(B#@#5"1C+I!52#6-#!-"H2@G#02#*#I2-L#A+H2#@#5"#9IA%02#!5A2#12'4 2 55H 1@) 2) 1)0A%02#4142'4 2 5(2#12'4 2 5C#01B#@#5"A%02#'41"@#5"+#7-(Lesson Study) 3)1(42'4 2 5A%0-1%1)L2'4 2 5(2#*1*8A%02#"-!#129I#4+2#B#@#5"%D2##0@!45H@G##!A%0@*I2'2!I2'+I2C*2"-2 5) 4)2#*1*8@ 4-L#A%0@ 4*21 1. -@I2@7I-+2 (Content Scope) #0 2#5HC IC2#'41" 7- #9B#@#5"!1"!(6)2C@@!7- 2 8 !%5K+%4 #0@(5 3' 475  2*2(6)2 3' 6 A+H (Changchun No.1 Secondary School, Jilin Provincial Experimental Secondary School, Changchun Jiutai Experimental Secondary School, Changchun Yang zheng Secondary School, Affiliated Secondary School of Northeast Normal University A%0 Changchun Wen li Secondary School) 2. #0 2#A%0%8H!1'-"H2 #0-I'" 2.1 #0 2#5HC IC2#'41" 7- #9B#@#5"!1"!(6)2C@@!7- 2 8 !%5K+%4 #0@(5 3' 475  2*2(6)2 3' 6 A+H (Changchun No.1 Secondary School, Jilin Provincial Experimental Secondary School, Changchun Jiu tai Experimental Secondary School, Changchun Yang zheng Secondary School, Affiliated Secondary School of Northeast Normal University A%0 Changchun Wen li Secondary School) 2.2 %8H!1'-"H25HC IC2#'41" 3' 210  #0-I'"#92B#@#5"!1"!(6)2 6 A+H 3+2%8H!1'-"H2B"C I2#2-@# 5HA%0!-#LA (Krejcie & Morgan, 1970, pp. 607-610) B"C I2#*8H!1'-"H2A 1I 9!4 (stratified random sampling) 2!2-B#@#5" 3.1'A#5H(6)2C2#'41"#1I5I #0-I'" 2 I2 15I 3.1 1'A#-4*#0 DIAH 1) 2-B#@#5" 1. B#@#5"2@%G (#9 50 +#7-I-"'H2) 2. B#@#5"2%2 (#9 51 100 ) 3. B#@#5"2C+ H (#9 101 6ID) 2) #0*2#L2#32-#9 1. 1 15 5 2. 16 56ID 3.2 1'A#2! DIAH 2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9CB#@#5"!1"!(6)2C@@!7- 2 8 !%5K+%4 #0-I'" 4 I2 7- 1) 2#12'2!#9I'4 2 5 2) 1)0A%02#4142'4 2 5 3) 1(4A%0-1%1)L2'4 2 5 4) 2#*1*8@ 4-L#A%0@ 4*21 4"2!(1L@ 20 1.2#12'4 2 5#9(Teacher Professional Development):2#12'4 2 5#9+!2"6#0'2#5H#912'2!#9I2'4 2 5*!##0I22#*-A%08%1)02'4 2 5-"H2H-@7H-%- H'-2 5H22#@#5"#9I-"H2*!H3@*!-2#*0I-4H-2#4142#*-A%02#!5*H'#H'!C4##!*1*82'4 2 5#0'2#5I!5%1)0#0"0"2'@GD2! H'-2 5A%06I-"9H1#4B"D!HDI@5H"'I-@5"2#@4BC#018%@H21IAH"1DI#1-44%2* 2A'%I-!-L#-B#@#5"A%02#*1*8@ 4*21 2.#9B#@#5"!1"!(6)2(Secondary School Teachers):+!2"6#9#032#@G!@'%25H414+I25H*-CB#@#5"!1"!(6)21H'DA%0#14 -+%1C2#12#@#5"2#*-A%09A%1@#5"C2#(6)25ID!H#'!9I#4+2#+#7-@I2+I25HH2"#4+2#-7HF@7H-C+I@4'2!*-%I--2'4 2 5A%0'2!I-2#I22#12'4 2 5-%8H!1'-"H2 3.2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9(Promoting Teacher Professional Development):+!2"6#0'2#5HB#@#5"A%0+H'"222#(6)25H@5H"'I-1C+I!5+%1#01A%02#*1*82#@4B2'4 2 5-#9H22#1'2@ 4*212#1*###1"2#A%0!2#2#I22##4+2#2#(6)25I!8H(6)22#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9C#01B#@#5"B"@I5H2##1#9I-#9H-!2#2#*1*81%H2' 4.2#*1*82B#@#5"(School Support):+!2"6!2#2#*1*8H2F5HB#@#5"1C+I@7H-2#12'4 2 5#9H22#*#I2#02#1*###1"2#A%0A'414I22##4+2#!2#2#@+%H25I#'!62#*1*8I2B"2"2#1*##@'%2A%02##0*22@ 4-L# 5.2#12'4 2 5C#01B#@#5"(School-based Professional Development):+!2"64##!2#12'4 2 55H1A%03@42# 2"CB#@#5"B"-42@I2+!2"2#12-B#@#5"A%0'2!I-2#5HAI#4-#9@I2#9#22#2#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5@I212#4142#*-#4 6. 8! 2#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5(Professional Learning Communities):+!2"6#9A--L#2#@#5"#9I5H#9#H'!!7-1-"H2H-@7H-@7H-122#*-H22#4*1!1L'2!*0I-4#H'!1A%02#A%@%5H"#0*2#LB"!5+I25H+%1C2#*H@*#4!4*1!1L2'4 2 5A%02#@4B#H'!1-#9 7.#0"0@'%22#4142-#9(Years of Teaching Experience):+!2"63'5*0*!5H#94142I22#*-C2#(6)25IC I@G1' 5I'1*31 - H'122#C*2"-2 5-#9A%0C I'4@#20+L'2!AH2-2##1#9IH-2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5CAH%0 H'-2 5 8.2-B#@#5"(School Size):+!2"62-L#5H3+23'#9A%01@#5"CB#@#5"C2#(6)25IC I@G1'A#*31 5H*0I-@7H-D-L#A%0C I'4@#20+L'2!AH2-2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5 2"CI#4-L#5HAH21 9.B-2*C2#12'4 2 5(Professional Development Opportunities):+!2"6B-2*H2F5H#9*2!2#@I262#6-#!2#A%@%5H"22#*-A%0#1"2#@*#4!*#I2(1" 2C H'-2 51I 2"CA%0 2"-B#@#5" 10.* 2A'%I-!2#12#9(Teacher Development Environment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arling-HammondA%00(2017)@*-@4H!@4!'H22#12'4 2 5#9'#9!-'H2@G#0'2#H-@7H-%- H'-2 5-#9#0*44%-2#12'4 2 56I-"9H1#4-B#@#5"2#*1*8@ 4-L#A%0#0*2#L2#@#5"#9I-#9C* 2A'%I-!2#*-#44##!2#12'4 2 55HA"--2@7H-D-L#-B#@#5"!1D!H*2!2#H-C+I@42#@%5H"A%5H"1H"7C'452#*-DI Avalos(2011)22#'2'41"*2%-"H2#-%8! 5IC+I@+G'H22#12'4 2 5#9D!H@5"#-%8!2#@4H!9'2!#9IA%01)0@H21IAH"1#'!62#121(42'4 2 5-1%1)L2'4 2 5A%0'2!!8H!1H-"H2H-@7H-H-2#122#*-!8!!-5I"2"A'4C+I'I2'H2%%1L-2#6-#! 2"-A%0@I2@ 4#8-#9C#0'2#@4B2'4 2 5 OECD(2019)22#'4@#20+LI-!9%TALIS#08'H22#12'4 2 5#95H!58 2*9!1!5@I2+!2" 1@@ 7H-!B"-"H2C%I 412#4142#*-A%0DI#12#*1*822#1'2@ 4*21A%0#1"2#5H!1HC#01B#@#5"I-I@+%H25I@I"I32*31 --L#B#@#5"C2#12'4 2 5#9A%0C+I@+8%*1*85H 1@*3+#12#'4@#20+L2!8!!-2##4+2#2#(6)2 Schleicher(2020) 5IC+I@+G@4H!@4!'H2 2"CI#4-2#4#92#(6)2-"H2H-@7H-2#12'4 2 5#9%2"@G-L#0-*31 -2#319A%B#@#5"2##1#9I-#9H-2#*1*85HAI#42B#@#5"@ H2#1*##@'%22#1+2#1"2#A%02#*1*8I22##4+2#*H%B"#H-'2!@G!C-#9C2#!5*H'#H'!C4##!2#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5 B"*#82'41"*2%A*C+I@+G6'2!@I2C#H'!1'H22#12'4 2 5#9@G#9A-2#@4B2'4 2 55H6I-"9H1#4@I#0'2#A%06H2-L#'2!@+GI-5I@G7I22$)55H*31 *3+#12#(6)22#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#92!8!!-2##4+2#2#(6)2C2#(6)2#1I5I 2.1.2A'4A%0#4@ 4B"2"-2#12'4 2 5#9C2'41"-5 GuMingyuan(2016) 5IC+I@+G'H2 2"CI#4-2#4#92#(6)21I7I2-"H2H-@7H-C#0@(52#12'4 2 5#9H-"F9!-'H2@G#22*31 C2#"#018 22#(6)22'41" 2"C#0@(C#0@G5I!5'2!@ 7H-!B"-"H2C%I 41B"2"3%1#9A%0A'414I22##4+2#B#@#5"AH222'41"*2%5H@I#0'2#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5-#9C#018%2'41"-5!142#22#12'4 2 5#9 2"CI#-@ 4B"2"A%0@ 4*21 YeLan(2015)(6)22#12'4 2 5#92!8!!--2#@4B%- 5'4-#9B"@I'H22#12'4 2 5D!H@5"@5H"'I-12#@4H!9*!##0@H21IAH"1#'!62##0+1#9I68H22'4 2 5A%0'2!+!2"--2 5!8!!-5I"2"A'4C+I'I2'H21)02@4+#7-%%1L22#6-#!A%0@I#0*2#L2#12A-L#'!-#9 ZhongBinglin(2017)@*-'H22#12'4 2 5#9I--2(1"2#*1*8@ 4*215H!1HA%0@G#0B" 5IC+I@+G'H24##!2#6-#!5H#01#02"D!H@5"-*3+#12#*H@*#4!2#@4B2'4 2 5#0"0"2'!8!!-5I@ 7H-!B"2#12'4 2 5#9@I212#319A%B#@#5"A%0A'414I22##4+2#2#(6)2-"H2 1@A%0@I"I3'2!#14 ---L#B#@#5"C2#*1*82#12#9 LiZhengtao(2018)@*-@4H!@4!'H22'41"@5H"'12#12'4 2 5#9'#I2'I2!2#(6)2'H2#9@I2#H'!2#6-#!#0@ CA%0'#!8H@ID5H'455H#9#1#9IA%0#0@!42#*1*82#12'4 2 5 2"C#4-B#@#5"!8!!-5I@I2-2##1#9I-#9C201'A#*7H-%2#0+'H22#1'2@ 4*2112#4142'4 2 5 WangBenlu(2019)22#'41"@ 4#01)L'H22##1#9I-#9H-2#*1*82#12'4 2 5C#01B#@#5"!5'2!*1!1L-"H2!51"*31 1'2!@G!C-#9C2#!5*H'#H'!C4##!2#@#5"#9I2'4 2 52'41"5IA*C+I@+G'H2A!I0-"9H 2"CI@7H-D@ 4*215H%I2"%612##0@!42#*1*82#12'4 2 5-#9-2AH21-"H2!2 6H*H'C+ H@42'2!AH2I2A'4142##4+2#A%0* 2A'%I-!-L#-B#@#5" "#'!A%I'2'41" 2"C#0@(*0I-C+I@+G62#@%5H"A%2!8!!-5H@I2#6-#!D*9H2#C+I'2!*31 1#0*2#L2#12-#9 2"C#4-L#-B#@#5"!26I-"H2D#G2!2'41"3'!2"1!8H@I2#'4@#20+L@ 4B"2"C#01!+ 205H2'41"@ 4#01)L5H#'*-2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9C#01B#@#5"!1"!(6)22!8!!-2##1#9I-#9C#01 9!4 2"1!5-"9H-"H231 2.1.32#12'4 2 5#92!8!!-2##4+2#2#(6)2 Bush(2016) 5IC+I@+G'H22#'41"I22##4+2#2#(6)2!8H@ID5H2#3'2!@I2C'H2B#@#5"C20-L2#-"H2@G22#!5-44%H-$4##!-*!2 4H22#1'2#0@ 4*21A%0A'414I22##4+2#-"H2D#2!8!!-5I2#12'4 2 5#9D!H'#9!-'H2@G@5"%%1L22#@#5"#9I*H'8%-#9@H21IAH'#9!-'H2@G#22#L5H@ 7H-!B"-"H2C%I 41'455H#02##4+2#-B#@#5"*#I2A%0D'I 6H@7H-D5H@-7I-H-2#@4B2'4 2 5!8!!-1%H2'3C+I'2!*C@%5H"22#!5*H'#H'!-#9C4##!-#!D*9H#4@ 4-L2#5H2#12'4 2 5@46I OECD(2015)@I"I3'H2#0*44%-2#12'4 2 5#96I-"9H1'H2B#@#5"*2!2#1C+I!52#*1*8@ 4*21-"H2H-@7H-+#7-D!H 6H#'!6B"2"5H!5'2!!1H2#1*##@'%2A%02#@I26#1"2##2"2 5IC+I@+G'H2A!I#90!5A#9C2'4 2 5*9AHG-2#0*'2!"2%32C2#!5*H'#H'!12#@#5"#9I-"H2H-@7H-+22#*1*8I22##4+2#D!H@5"-I-*1@5I*0I-C+I@+G6'2!*31 -@7H-D2##4+2#C#01B#@#5"5H!5H-#0*2#L2#12'4 2 5 Hallinger(2018)@*-2!8!!- 2'09I3CB#@#5"'H22#12'4 2 5#9'#9#'!D'ICA12B#@#5"B"#'!2#1*4C-9I3@5H"'12#22#*-#02##0@!4A%02#1*###1"2#%I'*H%B"#H-B-2*5H#90!5*H'#H'!C2#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5@!7H-2#12'4 2 599#22#@I21A'4142##4+2#C 5'4#03'1G!5A'BI!5H0%2"@G*H'*31 -2'4 2 5-#9 SkaalvikA%0Skaalvik(2017)22#'41"@ 4#01)L'H22##1#9I-#9H-2#*1*82H2"#4+2#3+I25H@G1'@ 7H-!*31 #0+'H2A'4142##4+2#1$4##!2'4 2 5#9!1#0@!42#*1*8I22#12'4 2 5D!HC H2#0@5"I-11-"H2@G22#AH22#414#4-H2"#4+2#@ H2#1*##@'%2-"H2@5"-*3+#14##!2#@#5"#9IA%02#"-!#1'2!"2"2!2'4 2 5-#9 HoyA%0Miskel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arling-Hammond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valos(2011) 5I'H2B#2#12'4 2 55H@ 7H-!B"-"H2C%I 412#414C 1I@#5"!5A'BI!H-C+I@42#@%5H"A%$4##!2#*--"H2"1H"7-"H2D#G2!'####!*2%3'!2!8H@I5H%1)0-B#A#!5H!5#0*44%!2'H22#'4@#20+L'H2@7H-D@ 4-L2#!5-44%H-2##0@!4-#9H-B#A#!@+%H21I-"H2D# Schleicher(2020)@I'2!*31 -2#1'2@ 4*21A%02#*1*8I2#1"2#H-2#@#5"#9I-#9 2"CB#@#5"AH2#(6)2'41"@ 4#01)L!1C+I'2!*31 1#-B"2"A%0B#*#I2@ 4#0!2'H22#*3#'#0*2#L@ 4-1'4*1"-#9H-2#*1*8I22#12'4 2 5 2"CI@7H-D-L2#5HAH21 B"*#82'41"*2%DIC+I7I22$)5A%0@ 4#01)L5H@I!AGH-'2!@I2C@5H"'12#12'4 2 5#9-"H2D#G2!"1!52#C+I'2!*31 H-I231H-'455H#9#1#9I2#*1*822##4+2#C#01B#@#5"B"@ 20C#4#01 9!4 2A%0B#@#5"!1"!(6)2@ 207I5H 2.2.22'41"-5@5H"'12#12'4 2 5#9 Gu Mingyuan(2016) 5I'H22#12'4 2 5#9!5'2!@ 7H-!B"-"H2C%I 412#4#92#(6)2A%0B"2"3%1#9-5!2-"H2"2'22'41" 2"C#0@(3'!2(6)22#12#9 2"CI#-B"2"B"!8H@I5H2#--A@ 4*21#02#6-#!A%0%D2#(6)2H-@7H-5H+H'"222#(6)211I6I Ye Lan(2015)@I2#@4B2'4 2 5%- 5'4-#9A%0C+I'2!*31 12#@*#4!*#I28H22'4 2 5A%0'2!+!2"--2 5A!I!8!!-5I0 H'""2"'2!@I2C@5H"'12#12'4 2 5#9C+I'I26IAH2'41"5H@5H"'I-!1- 4#2"C#01A'4!2'H22#'4@#20+L'H2A'414I22##4+2#-B#@#5"!5-44%H-#0*2#L2'4 2 5-#9-"H2D# Zhong Binglin(2017)@+G'H22#*1*8@ 4*21-"H2@G#0@G@7H-D*31 H-'2!H-@7H--2#12'4 2 5#92'41"C#0@(3'!26'4@#20+L2#*#I2#02#6-#!#9A%0#9A2#12C#01B#@#5"B"@I'2!*31 -2#1'2@ 4*215H!1H-"H2D#G2!2'41"@+%H25I!1!8H@I5H2#--A#0!2'H22#(6)2'H2#9#0*1#0@+%H25I-"H2D#C#42#32#4-B#@#5" Li Zhengtao(2018)@*-'H22#'41"'#I2'I2!2###"2"4##!2#6-#!A%0+1!2C+I'2!*31 12##0@!4-#9H-2#*1*8I22#12'4 2 5 2"CB#@#5"A!I0!5I-@*-@ H5IAH2'41"@ 4#01)L5HC I2##1#9I-#9@GI-!9%+%1"1!53'H-I231 Wang Benlu(2019)'H22##1#9I-#9H-2#*1*8I22#12'4 2 5C#01B#@#5"!5'2!*1!1L-"H2C%I 41'2!@G!C-#9C2#!5*H'#H'!C2#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5I-I5I 5IC+I@+G'2!*31 -!8!!-2##1#9I-#9C2#3'2!@I2C%%1L-2#12'4 2 5-"H2D#G2!2'41"@ 4#01)LC#01 9!4 25H!8H@IB#@#5"!1"!(6)2A%0'4@#20+L'2!AH2 2"CI@7H-D-L2#5HAH21"1!5-"9H-"H231 B"*#82'41"-5DIC+I2#- 4#2"-"H2'I2'2@5H"'1#-@ 4*21A%02#3@4B"2"5H@5H"'I-12#12'4 2 5#9-"H2D#G2!2'41"@ 4#01)L5H(6)2'H2#9#1#9I2#*1*8I22#12'4 2 5C#01B#@#5"-"H2D#B"@ 20C#4 9!4 2A%0B#@#5"!1"!(6)2@ 207I5H"1!5-"9H-"H2H-I231 2.2.32'41"@5H"'12#12'4 2 5#9C#0@(D" *3120##!2#2#(6)2A+H 24-#0@(D"(2018)@I'H22#12'4 2 5#9@G%"8L*31 C2#"#018 22#(6)21I7I22'41"-D"C#0"0+%1DIH-"F@%5H"'2!*C2B#2#6-#!A#'!(9"LD*9H2#12'4 2 5C#01B#@#5"A%02#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5-"H2H-@7H- 2"CB#@#5" Kanjanawasee(2016)A*C+I@+GH22#(6)2'41"@ 4#01)L'H29I#4+2#*2(6)2!52*31 C2#3+B-2*C2#12'4 2 5-#9H22#'2A2#1*###1"2#A%0%D2#*1*82'41"@+%H25I!1'4@#20+L'H2A'414I22##4+2#!5-44%H-2#!5*H'#H'!-#9C4##!2#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5-"H2D# 2'41"-D"3'!2C I'452#*3#'@7H-@GI-!9%2##1#9I-#9H-2#*1*8I22#12'4 2 5B"@I'H22##0@!4@ 4-1'4*1"-#9@GI-!9%5H!58H2C2#3'2!@I2C#0*2#L2#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5A'2@ 4#0@5"'455I!5'2!*-%I-12#--A2#'41"-2#(6)2#1I5I +1'I-'41"5HDIH-"C#0@(D"DIAH2#12'4 2 5C#01B#@#5" 8! A+H2#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5A%0'2!6-CC2-#9+%2"2'41" 5I'H22##1#9I-#9H-2#*1*82B#@#5"!5-44%-"H2!2H-2#!5*H'#H'!C4##!2#12'4 2 5 -"H2D#G2!2'41"-D"3@42# 2"CI#02##4+2#2#(6)2A%0#4B"2"5HAH225'2!AH2I2B#*#I22#319A%A'414I22##4+2#A%0@7H-D@ 4-L2#-B#@#5"3C+I%2#'41"2#4D"D!H*2!2#3!2#0"8LC I1B#@#5"!1"!(6)2C5DIB"# B"*#82'41"-D"C+IA'2@ 4#0@5"'455H@G#0B" LH-2#(6)22#12'4 2 5#92!8!!-2##1#9I-#9-"H2D#G2!'2!AH2I2#431'2!*2!2#C2#3%2#'41"@+%H25IDC I1@7H-D@ 4 9!4 2A%0@ 4-L2#-B#@#5"!1"!(6)2C# 2 8DIB"# 2.2.4*#8 H-'H2-2'41" Darling-HammondA%00(2017)A%0OECD(2019)A*C+I@+G'H22'41"22 24DI*#I2'2!@I2C-"H2%6 6I@5H"'12#12'4 2 5#9C20#0'2#5HH-@7H-A%01-"9HC#4 6H!5'2!@ 7H-!B"-"H2C%I 41* 2A'%I-!-B#@#5"2'41"@+%H25IC+I#222$)55H@I!AGC2#@ 7H-!B"2#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5@I21@7H-D-B#@#5"-"H2D#G2!2'41"22 24*H'C+ H!1!8H@ID5H2##08#9AA%0%"8L2#12'4 2 55H!5#0*44%05HC+I'2!*CH-I2I-"H-'455H#9#0@!4A%0#1#9I2#*1*8I22##4+2#C2#12'4 2 5 2"CI#42#32#03'1CB#@#5"B"@ 20C#4-B#@#5"!1"!(6)2 Gu Mingyuan(2016)A%0Zhong Binglin(2017)A*C+I@+G'H22'41"-5!5*H'*31 C2#'4@#20+L#-@ 4*21#02#6-#!#9A%02#3@4B"2"5H@5H"'I-12#12'4 2 5#92'41"C#0@(!1@I'2!*31 -2#*1*8-"H2@G#0A%0%D2#12C#01B#@#5"-"H2D#G2!2'41"3'!2"1-"9HC#01-2#--A@ 4*21A%02#- 4#2"@ 4B"2"2#(6)2'41"@ 4#01)L5H*3#''H2#9#1#9I2#*1*82#12'4 2 5C#01B#@#5"-"H2D#B"@ 20C#4B#@#5"!1"!(6)2@ 4 9!4 2"1H-I231 Kanjanawasee(2016)A%0*3120##!2#2#(6)2A+H 24-#0@(D"(2018)A*C+I@+G'H22'41"-D"C+I1'-"H2@ 4#0@5"'455H!58H2B"C IA*3#'2##1#9I-#9@7H-(6)22#*1*82#12'4 2 52'41"@+%H25I@I'2!*31 -#0*2#L@ 4-1'4*1"-#9-"H2D#G2!'2!AH2I2#02#319A%A'414I22##4+2#A%0B#*#I2-L2#-B#@#5"3C+I%2#'41"2#4D"D!H*2!2#3!2#0"8LC I1#4B#@#5"!1"!(6)2C5DIB"# Avalos(2011)A%0Schleicher(2020)@*-'H2A!I2'41"I22#12'4 2 50C+I'2!*31 12-* 2A'%I-!B#@#5"!26IAH2'41"3'!2"1'4@#20+L2#12'4 2 5#92!8!!-B"2"#01!+ 2+#7-2!8!!-#0*44%-B#2#'2!@ 7H-!B"#0+'H2A'414I22##4+2#-B#@#5"1#0*2#L2#32#4-#9"1D!HDI#12#*3#'@ 4#01)L-"H2@5"- LiZhengtao(2018)@+G'H22#'41"'#I2'I2!2#-42"4##!2#12'4 2 5D*9H2#'4@#20+L'H2#9#0@!42#*1*85HDI#1C#4B#@#5"-"H2D#-"H2D#G2!"1!52'41"D!H!215HC I2##1#9I-#9@G8'4@#20+L+%1#I-!1I9#22#1'A#@ 4-L2#5H-2!5-44%H-2##1#9I1I HoyA%0Miskel(2013) 5I'H2%1)0@ 4-L2#@ H2B#@#5"!5-44%H-A'414I22##4+2##9A2#*7H-*2#A%02#1*###1"2#-"H2D#G2!2'41"5H9#22#1'A#@ 4-L2#@+%H25I@I212#'4@#20+L@ 4#01)L@5H"'12#12'4 2 5#9"1!5312'41"*H'C+ H!1!-2#12'4 2 5@G#0'2#5H@+!7-1B"D!HDI42#2'H2'2!AH2I2@7H-D-L2#-B#@#5"-23C+I#0*2#L-#9AH21-"H2D# Huberman(1989)A%0Day(2017)@I'H2 H'122#2'4 2 5-#9!5-44%H-'2!I-2#A%02#-*-H-2#*1*8A!I$)5 H'122#'4 2 509%H2'6H-"C2'41"AHG!193@*-C@ 4A'4!2'H22#3DC IC2#(6)2@ 4#01)L5H@#5"@5"2##1#9I-#9C H'#0*2#L2#*-5HAH21 Skaalvik A%0 Skaalvik(2011)A*C+I@+G'H22##1#9I-#9H-2#*1*82-L2#!5-44%-"H2!2H-2#!5*H'#H'!2'4 2 5-"H2D#G2!2'41"5H*22##1#9I-#9'2!AH22! H'122#'4 2 5A%0@7H-D@ 4-L2#@I2D'IC#-2#'4@#20+L@5"'1"1DII-"B"@ 20C#4-B#@#5"!1"!(6)2 -25I2'41"@ 4 9!4 25H!8H@I 20'1--@ 5"@+7--5"1!5-"9H-"H231B#*#I22##4+2#2#(6)2%1)0#0 2#A%0@7H-D2*1!@(#)4- 9!4 25IAH227I5H5H!5'2!@#4 2@(#)4!2'H2%2#'41"2 9!4 2-7H-2D!H*0I-'2!@G#4-#9B#@#5"!1"!(6)2C# 2 8!%5K+%4DI-"H2#I' @!7H-42#2#H'!1*2!2##08 H-'H2-2'41"DI+%2"#02##02#A#"122'41"@ 4#01)L5H(6)22#12'4 2 5#92!8!!-2##1#9I-#9 2"CI#4@ 20-B#@#5"!1"!(6)2#02#5H*-2'41"5H!5-"9H!1@I@ 202#12#@ 4*21+#7-8%1)0*H'8%-#9B"D!HDI9#22#11"@+%H25IC#-2#'4@#20+L@5"'1#02#5H*2!2'41"5HC I5#0*2#L2#*-A%02B#@#5"#H'!1@7H--42"'2!AH2-#0*2#L2#12'4 2 5"1!5I-"A%0#02#5H*5H+%12@ 4 9!4 22 20'1--@ 5"@+7--5"1D!H@5"- H-'H2@+%H25I*0I-'2!3@G-2#(6)2'41"@ 4#01)L5HC I!8!!-2##1#9I-#99#22#%1)0 H'122#'4 2 5-#91@7H-D@ 4-L2#-B#@#5"A%01I-"9H#4B#@#5"!1"!(6)2@ 4 9!4 2-"H2 1@11I2#(6)22#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9C+!9H#9B#@#5"!1"!(6)2C# 2 8!%5K+%46*2!2#C+I+%12@ 4#01)L5H!5'2!+!2"@7H--*-I-31@+%H25IA%0@*#4!*#I2-L'2!#9I@ 4 9!4 2C+I1*222##4+2#2#(6)2DI-"H2!51"*31  Fullan(.02N B j    V X Z \ ^ ` b d . 0 d f | ҮҔҔҔ҂#h5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ 2htht5CJ$OJPJQJ\^JaJ$nHtHjhtUmHnHu+ht5CJ$OJQJ\^JaJ$nHo(tH*htht5CJ$OJPJQJ\^JaJ$-htht5CJ$OJPJQJ\^JaJ$/02j  V X Z \ ^ ` b d 0 f  gdtgdt$a$gdt . ^`"$&| $ FX a$gdt FX gdt X gdt X gdt$a$gdt , . d ^` "$&|ӿӫӿӫӿӿӿ}eeee}.h5*ht5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ nHtH1h5*ht5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ nHo(tH)htht5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ &htht5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ &h5*ht5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ ,h5*ht5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o()h5*ht5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ ' "&>d gd LgdA$a$gdA$a$gdx $ FX a$gdx FX gdt $ FX a$gdt "&,.0<>@HJLbdfnpruuuuc#h5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ  hx 5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ &hx hx 5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ #hx 5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ &hx hx 5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ )hx hx 5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ ,h5*ht5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o(&h5*ht5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ 24<ϻww`Q<<((&hyhy5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ )hyhy5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ hACJ OJQJ^JaJ o(,hhA5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o(hACJ OJQJ^JaJ &hA5CJ$OJQJ\^JaJ$o( hx 5CJ$OJQJ\^JaJ$ hA5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ &hA5CJ(OJQJ\^JaJ(o(,hS-hA5CJ(OJQJ\^JaJ(o(1hXht5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ nHo(tH4>("'+149=RBGJJ K"KKLL n`ngdoc WD`gdoc gd L WD`gdoc gdy & F gdy<>x>Bxx!&"("%x&''H()x*++$,-x.11162445x6999:===N>APBRBExFFGIIxJJJJKKK̵,hwhNp5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o(,hwh_5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o( hA5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ #hyhyCJ OJQJ^JaJ  hyhyCJ OJQJ^JaJ <K K"K&KKKKK.LLLLLL$M&M(M*M,MǵǢǵǑlWF3%hocCJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH hochocCJ OJQJ^JaJ )hwh5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o(,hwh5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o(hACJ OJQJ^JaJ hACJ OJQJ^JaJ o(%hyCJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH#hyhyCJ OJQJ^JaJ  hyhyCJ OJQJ^JaJ hACJ OJQJ^JaJ o(/hB4Kh_5B*CJ OJQJ\^JaJ phLL&M(MNNN O"OtQvQrRRR(SrS:VWWXZ WD,`gd)x gd)x WD`gd)x WD`gdoc gd L `gdA,MMNNNNNNNOO O"O$PFPjPPPPJQtQvQQQRRpRrRܻp^M^M^M^MM^^MM^M h)xh)xCJ OJQJ^JaJ #h)xh)xCJ OJQJ^JaJ hACJ OJQJ^JaJ o(&hwhg5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ hB4K5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ ,hwhg5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o(hCJ OJQJ^JaJ %hocCJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH hochocCJ OJQJ^JaJ #hochocCJ OJQJ^JaJ rRvRRRRRRR&S(S,SpSrSSSST T T*TULUTUpUUU8V:VVVWWWWXXXZZZZZZ*[ڻy&h^ hB4K5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ ,h^ hA5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o(,h^ h_5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o(h)xCJ OJQJ^JaJ h)xh)xCJ OJQJ^JaJ #h)xh)xCJ OJQJ^JaJ %h)xCJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH+ZZ,[.[\R\\\.]n]],^^^___8```,d2h4h WD,`gd~W WD`gdG WD`gdZ1 gdA gd)x*[,[.[F[^[[[[[[[\\\\P\R\V\\\\\\\*].]4]l]n]t]]]]*^,^2^^^^^^^__"_n______`6`8`<```ȷȷȷȷȷȷȷȷȷȷȷȷȷȷȷȷȷ+h^ hGCJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH%h^ CJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH h^ hGCJ OJQJ^JaJ #h^ hGCJ OJQJ^JaJ #h^ hACJ OJQJ^JaJ o(&h^ h_5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ 8```aaaa"b&b(b2b6bbbbbFcJcccd*d,dddd eeeeeeef,f.f8f@ǵǵ||ǵg)h}*h}*5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o(+hHhHCJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH hHhHCJ OJQJ^JaJ #hHh}*CJ OJQJ^JaJ o(#hHhHCJ OJQJ^JaJ #hHh}*CJ OJQJ^JaJ &hHh}*CJ OJQJ^JaJ o(#hHh>CJ OJQJ^JaJ o('~*x"H<p>@bdƑ gd~W F`gd}* gd L $ Fa$ gdH$ FWD`a$ gdH$ F@WD`@a$ gdH@^`bdfh҂."N`bnp $&@Ƌҋԋĵllllllll%h2(CJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH#h~Wh~WCJ OJQJ^JaJ %hJfCJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH h~Wh~WCJ OJQJ^JaJ h}*CJ OJQJ^JaJ o(&hwh%J5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ hB4K5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ ,hwh%J5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o(*ƍލʏđƑȑʑ $&>ēҕԕ JXZprtdfhܶܶܶܶܶܶܶܶܶܶܶܶܥ h}*h>CJ OJQJ^JaJ %h2(CJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH%hJfCJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH h~Wh~WCJ OJQJ^JaJ #h~Wh~WCJ OJQJ^JaJ @Ƒfh6@.24JLЬ WD`gd2($a$ gd}*$a$gd}* `gd2( `gd}* gd L gd~Wh46BVX̠>@L,.02ĵ~i~i~iX h}*CJ OJQJ^JaJ o()h2(h2(5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ &h2(h2(5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ h2(h2(CJ OJQJ^JaJ #h2(h2(CJ OJQJ^JaJ h}*CJ OJQJ^JaJ o(&hwhg5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ hB4K5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ ,hwhg5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o(246BDJLrЬ֬ugUAA/#h(hACJ OJQJ^JaJ &h2(h2(5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ #h}*h}*CJ OJQJ^JaJ o(h}*CJ OJQJ^JaJ )h}*h}*5CJ$OJQJ\^JaJ$#h}*5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ  h}*5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ &h}*5CJ(OJQJ\^JaJ(o(,hS-h}*5CJ(OJQJ\^JaJ(o(#h2(5CJ(OJQJ\^JaJ()hKZhKZ5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o( ֬"$&*02|~ lnxzޮȵڵȵڍxaxQ>x$hAhACJ OJPJQJ^JaJ hACJ OJPJQJ^JaJ ,h(hACJ OJPJQJ^JaJ nHtH)hACJ OJPJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH(h(hACJ OJQJ^JaJ nHtH$h(hACJ OJPJQJ^JaJ %hACJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH#h(hACJ OJQJ^JaJ  h(hACJ OJQJ^JaJ 'hAhACJ OJPJQJ^JaJ Ь$~nJ thرD FdWD`gdA FdWD,`gdA FdWD`gdA dWD`gdA >FdWD`gdAޮHJLPRVX rtʶޒޥޒ}jU>U,h(hACJ OJPJQJ^JaJ nHtH)hACJ OJPJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH$h(hACJ OJPJQJ^JaJ (h(hACJ OJQJ^JaJ nHtH%hACJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH h(hACJ OJQJ^JaJ 'hAhACJ OJPJQJ^JaJ 'h(hACJ OJPJQJ^JaJ #h(hACJ OJQJ^JaJ hACJ OJPJQJ^JaJ tfhjntvֱرڱޱBDFJPRڻk삻삂[hACJ OJPJQJ^JaJ ,h(hACJ OJPJQJ^JaJ nHtH'hAhACJ OJPJQJ^JaJ %h[0CJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH#h(hACJ OJQJ^JaJ  h(hACJ OJQJ^JaJ hACJ OJQJ^JaJ #hAhACJ OJQJ^JaJ %hACJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tHӾqZF1)h[0CJ OJPJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH'h(hACJ OJPJQJ^JaJ ,h(hACJ OJPJQJ^JaJ nHtH)hACJ OJPJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH h(hACJ OJQJ^JaJ 'h[0h[0CJ OJPJQJ^JaJ %h[0CJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH(h(hACJ OJQJ^JaJ nHtH+h(hACJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH+hAhACJ OJQJ^JaJ nHtH jl~tdQ<(h(hACJ OJQJ^JaJ nHtH$h(h[0CJ OJPJQJ^JaJ h[0CJ OJPJQJ^JaJ hACJ OJPJQJ^JaJ 'h[0h[0CJ OJPJQJ^JaJ )h[0CJ OJPJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH'h(hACJ OJPJQJ^JaJ ,h(hACJ OJPJQJ^JaJ nHtH)hACJ OJPJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH$h(hACJ OJPJQJ^JaJ lfҶ4ڷܷ24w$dWD`a$gdq> $da$gdq>  gd L dWD`gd[0$ Fd`a$ gd[0$ Fd`a$ gdA FdWD`gdA$ FdWD`a$ gd[0 df|~жҶ246ŰpŰpXC(h(hACJ OJQJ^JaJ nHtH/h(hACJ OJPJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH'h(hACJ OJPJQJ^JaJ )h[0CJ OJPJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH,h(hACJ OJPJQJ^JaJ nHtH)hACJ OJPJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH$h(hACJ OJPJQJ^JaJ 'h[0h[0CJ OJPJQJ^JaJ %h[0CJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH68طڷܷ024>fhb>@ȶmV>>VV>V>>>V/hq> hq> CJ OJPJQJ^JaJ nHtH,hq> hq> CJ OJPJQJ^JaJ nHtH&hq> CJ OJPJQJ^JaJ nHtH5hq> hq> 5CJ OJPJQJ\^JaJ nHtH2hq> hq> 5CJ OJPJQJ\^JaJ nHtH#h}*5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o(%hACJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH#h[0h[0CJ OJQJ^JaJ #h(hACJ OJQJ^JaJ 4h@JzX&fn<$66$dWD`a$gdq> @X(20HJxz VXn $&Ddflnx鷜鷅-hq> hq> 5CJ OJPJQJ\^JaJ 5hq> hq> 5CJ OJPJQJ\^JaJ nHtH2hq> hq> 5CJ OJPJQJ\^JaJ nHtH/hq> hq> CJ OJPJQJ^JaJ nHtH,hq> hq> CJ OJPJQJ^JaJ nHtH-:<P "$84646ӻӻӻӻӻӻӻӻӡӻӻӻӻӻӻ5hq> hq> 5CJ OJPJQJ\^JaJ nHtH2hq> hq> 5CJ OJPJQJ\^JaJ nHtH/hq> hq> CJ OJPJQJ^JaJ nHtH,hq> hq> CJ OJPJQJ^JaJ nHtH*hq> hq> 5CJ OJPJQJ\^JaJ 46\P> N vf!"""" gdDQ gd L$dWD^`a$gdq> $dWD`a$gdq> Z\`zNPd>  < > L N V~tvdf!!""""缢А#h}*5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o(2hq> hq> 5CJ OJPJQJ\^JaJ nHtH'hq> hq> CJ OJPJQJ^JaJ ,hq> hq> CJ OJPJQJ^JaJ nHtH/hq> hq> CJ OJPJQJ^JaJ nHtH6""""N#P#R#p#$&&&&$)D)F)T)*+++0,. . .$0&0(0000000222222&5j5l5v5x556r8t8x8z88:t:v:~:::ȷȷ%hA9CJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH#hDQhDQCJ OJQJ^JaJ  hDQhDQCJ OJQJ^JaJ hDQCJ OJQJ^JaJ &hDQhDQ5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ )hDQhDQ5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ 9"P#R#&F)+ .&0(0002l5t8v:=*@,@@@B6EpGRInKMM gdDQ WD`gdDQ:t===>(@*@,@@@@BBBBE4E6EFnGpGHPIRIJlKnKLMMMMMMMN NRRRRRRRRRR4UV|V~V˶˶ˢ܁܁%hA9CJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tHhDQCJ OJQJ^JaJ &hDQhDQ5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ )hDQhDQ5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ  hDQ5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ hDQhDQCJ OJQJ^JaJ #hDQhDQCJ OJQJ^JaJ 2MMMR~VZ\ _JbdfimBq28:$& gdDQ WD`gdDQ~VVhYZZZ Z6Z\\\^_ ___$_`bHbJb\blbtbdddddddfffi~iijmmn@qBqPq`0268:)hDQhDQ5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ U%h"S<CJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH#hDQhDQCJ OJQJ^JaJ  hDQhDQCJ OJQJ^JaJ A2016)*#8'H22#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 50#0*'2!*3@#GDI@!7H-2##4+2# 2'09I3@7H-D@ 4-L2#A%02##1#9I-#93@4D-"H2*-%I-1'2!D!H*-%I-#0+'H2-L#0-@+%H25I!13D*9H2#%-#0*44%-4##!2#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5 B"*#82'41"@+%H25I-"I3'H22#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9CB#@#5"!1"!!4DI93+B"4##!2#-#!@5"%31AH@424*1!1L5H 1 I-#0+'H2#02##4+2#$4##! 2'09I3@7H-D@ 4-L2#2#1*###1"2#A%02##1#9I-#9 6HDI#1-44%2 H'122#-2 5A%0#4-B#@#5" '2!@I2C5H"2"--D5IC+I2$)55H%6 6I"4H6I*3+#12#'4@#20+L'H2#0*2#L2#*-A%02B#@#5"*H%H-2##1#9I-#9@5H"'12#*1*82#12'4 2 5CB#@#5"!1"!-@!7- 2 8-"H2D# SkaalvikA%0Skaalvik(2011) 5IC+I@+G'H22##1#9I-#9H-2#*1*8@42#0*2#LC 5'42#32#03'1-"H2H-@7H-!2'H20!222#1'2@ 4*21@5"#1I#2'D!H'H20@G2#4@( 1I@#5"5H!8H122#*H@*#4!'2!#H'!!7-#0+'H2#9+#7-2#5HH2"#4+2#C+I2#"-!#1H-'2!"2"2!-#9%I'!5*H'+%H-+%-!2##0@!4-#9H-2#*1*82#12'4 2 5 HoyA%0Miskel(2013)#08'H2'2!!5@*5"# 2--L2#!52*31 H-2#3+'2!2+'1-#9A'414I22##4+2#5H*!H3@*!- H'"@*#4!*#I2'2!D'I'2CA%0@4H!'2!@G!C-#9C2#%812#@4B2'4 2 5#0"0"2' 2.2.5!8!!-2##1#9I-#9C2'41"*2% SkaalvikA%0Skaalvik(2011) 5IC+I@+G'H22##1#9I@ 4-1'4*1"-#9H-* 2A'%I-!2#*1*82B#@#5"@G8@#4H!I*31 C2#3'2!@I2C$4##!2'4 2 5-#9C2'41"@5H"'12#12'4 2 5#92##1#9I-#9DI%2"@G1'A#*31 C2#-42"'2!AH2-%2#'41"!26I@#7H-"F 2'41"5H@5H"'I-A*C+I@+G'H2A!IB#@#5"01C+I!5B-2*C2#12'4 2 55H%I2"%612##1#9I-#9H-B-2*@+%H25I-2AH21-"H2!2'2!AH2C2##1#9I5I*2!2#*H%H-1(4-#9A%0#012#!5*H'#H'!C4##!2#12'4 2 5H-D 2.3 7I22$)5-2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9 2.3.1$)5 H'122#C-2 5#9A%02#12'4 2 5#9 Huberman (1989) @*-'H2 5'4'4 2 5-#912D2! H'#0"0--2 55H*2!2#3ADI AH%0 H'!5%1)0@ 20I2'2!1'%2'4 2 5 %31'2!*31  A%0'2!I-2#C2#12 #9C H'-2 55HAH21!1C+I'2!*31 1#0@G2'4 2 55HAH21 #9C H'@#4H!I-2 5!1!8H@ID5H2#12# 1I@#5"A%02#12'2!*2!2#I22#*- C05H#95H!5#0*2#L!26I!1C+I'2!*31 12#12'2!@ 5H"' 2  '2!@G-4*#02'4 2 5 A%02##1#8A'22#*- !8!!-5I*0I-C+I@+G'H2 '2!I-2#I22#12'4 2 5-#9D!HDI!5%1)0@+!7-11I+! Day (2017) @I'H2 H'#0"0--2 5#9!5-44%D!H@5"H-'2!I-2#2'4 2 5-#9@H21I AH"1*H%H-'455H#9#1#9IA%0#0@!42#*1*8I22#12'4 2 52B#@#5" @!7H-DI#12#*1*8C%1)0@5"'1 #9C H'-2 55HAH21-25'2!#0*2#L1IAH212!'2!2+'12'4 2 5A%0#0*2#L5H*1H*!!2 *H%C+I#9A2#12'4 2 5@5"'1H-C+I@4#0*2#L5HAH21C+!9H#9 Avalos (2011) 5IC+I@+G'H2 2#3!8!!- H'#0"0--2 5!2C IC2#'41"2#12'4 2 5#9 H'"-42"'2!AH2-#9A2#!5*H'#H'!A%0#01'2!91-#9H-4##!2#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5 2'41"@ 4#01)L'H2 #9C H'I-2 5!16H22#*1*85H!5B#*#I2A%0@G#0 C05H#95H!5#0*2#L!26I!1C+I'2!*31 1B-2*2#@#5"#9I5H"7+"8HA%0*2!2#3+4(2DII'"@- 6H*-%I-1A'22#*-5HDI12!2A%I' Hargreaves (2019) 5I'H2 '2!AH22! H'-2 50@+GDI 1@@G4@()C#4-B#@#5"!1"!(6)2 6H!5%1)0@HI2'2!@ 5H"' 2 @ 20'4 2 A#122#*- A%0'2! 1 I--2#12#@#5"2#*- 11"@+%H25I!5-44%H-'2!1'%A%0%31'2!*31 2'4 2 5-#9CAH%0 H'-2 5 A%0*H%H-2##0@!4-#9H-'2!@+!20*!A%0'2!@5"--2#*1*8I22#12'4 2 5 Darling-Hammond A%00 (2017) @+G'H2 %"8L2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 55HD!H366'2!AH2I2#0*2#L2#*- !1D!H*2!2#-*-'2!I-2#2'4 2 55H+%2+%2"-#9DI 11I #0"0@'%22#4142-#96@G11"*31 C2#3'2!@I2C'2!AH2-#0*2#L2#12'4 2 5 B"*#8 $)5 H'122#C-2 5#9 5IC+I@+G'H2 #0*2#L2#12'4 2 5-#9!5'2!*1!1L-"H2C%I 413A+H-#9C'# 5'4'4 2 5 2#-*--#9H-2#*1*8I22##4+2#@5"'16!5A'BI!AH21D2!#0*2#LA%0%31'2!*31 2-2 5-AH%0 !8!!-@ 4$)55I@G7I2*31 C2#'4@#20+L'2!AH2-2##1#9I-#9H-2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 52!#0"0@'%22#4142C2#(6)2#1I5I 2.3.2 $)52#*1*82-L#12#12'4 2 5#9 Eisenberger A%00 (1986) @*-$)52##1#9I2#*1*82-L2# B"-42"'H2 8%0121(4A%0$4##!-*-2!#015H'@2@ 7H-'H2-L2#C+I8H2H-%2-A%0C*HCH-2#12- @!7H-*!2 4-L2##1#9I'H2!52#*1*8-"H2@I!AG '@2!5A'BI!5H0A*'2!91A%02#!5*H'#H'!C2!26I $)55I 5IC+I@+G'H2 2##03--L2#*H%H-$4##!-8%H2  2##1#9I -8%@G*31  Skaalvik A%0 Skaalvik (2011) 3$)52#*1*82-L2#@I2*9H2#'41"22#(6)2 A%0@I'H2 2##1#9I-#9H-* 2A'%I-!2#*1*82B#@#5"!52*31 H-A#9C2'4 2 5A%02#!5*H'#H'!C4##!2'4 2 5 #9D!HDI-*-@5"H-B"2"+#7-#05H@G22#@H21I AH-*-H-'455H#0@+%H21I93D414#4C 5'4#03'1-B#@#5" OECD (2019) #08'H2 #0*44%-2#*1*8I22#12'4 2 5D!HDI6I-"9H@5"AH2#!5!2#2#*1*8 AH6I-"9H1'H2#9#1#9I'H2!2#2#@+%H21I!5'2!+!2" !5'2!H-@7H- A%0*-%I-1'2!I-2#2'4 2 5-+#7-D!H !8!!-5I 5IC+I@+G'H2 2#3'2!@I2C%#0-2#*1*82H2"#4+2# 3@GI-42#22##0@!4@ 4-1'4*1"-#9I'" Fullan (2016) 5I'H2 $4##!2'4 2 5-#993+B"A'4142##4+2#C 5'4#03'1!2'H22B#2#@ 204+#7-@-*2#B"2" 2#C*HC-"H2H-@7H--H2"#4+2#H-2#12'4 2 5#9 H22#1*##@'%2 2#*7H-*2# A%02#"-!#18H22'4 2 5 !52*31 H-'2!@G!C-#9C2#!5*H'#H'!12#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5 Hargreaves (2019) @I'H2 C#4-B#@#5"!1"!(6)25H!5A#1I22#*-*9 2##1#9I-#9H-2#*1*82-L2#!5'2!*31 @G4@() @!7H-#9#1#9I'H22#*1*82H2"#4+2#D!H@5"- 2#!5*H'#H'!C4##!2#12'4 2 5-2931 A!I'H20!5B-2*1%H2'C@ 4#9AG2! B"*#8 $)52#*1*82-L2# 5IC+I@+G'H2 -44%-2##4+2#B#@#5"H-2#12'4 2 5#9@46IH22##1#9I-#9@G+%1 A!I0!52#1'2#0@ 4*215H%I2"%61 AH'2!AH2C2##1#9I2#*1*8-#9-23D*9H'2!AH2C#012#!5*H'#H'!2'4 2 5 !8!!-@ 4$)55I6C+I@+8%*1*85H 1@H-2#(6)22#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#92!8!!-2##1#9I-#9C2#'41"#1I5I 2.3.3 $)52##4+2#2#(6)2A%0-L2#-B#@#5" Bush (2011) @*-'H2 B#@#5"'#93'2!@I2CC20-L2#-"H2@G22# 6HB#*#I22##4+2# 2#1'2@ 4*21 A%0'1##!-L2# %I'3+#0*2#LC 5'4#03'1-*!2 4 4##!2'4 2 5-#9D!HDI@46I-"H2-4*#0 AH1-"9H 2"C#0'2#3@42--L2#B#@#5" !8!!-5I 5IC+I@+G'H2 B-2*C2#12'4 2 5DI#1-44%2@7H-D@ 4-L2# !2'H2'2!"2"2!*H'8%@5"-"H2@5"' Hoy A%0 Miskel (2013) @I'H2 %1)0@ 4-L2#-B#@#5" #'!6B#*#I22##4+2#A%0#0'2#1*4C !5-44%-"H2H-@7H-H-* 2A'%I-!2#32-#9 '2!AH2-%1)0@+%H25I-23D*9H'2!AH2C2#5H#9#0*A%0#1#9I2#*1*82H2"#4+2# #'!6B-2*C2#12'4 2 5CAH%0B#@#5" Leithwood A%00 (2019) 5I'H2 -44%-2##4+2#B#@#5"H-2#12'4 2 5-#9!1@46I2-I-! 2#1*4C@5H"'12##02" 2#02 2#1*###1"2# A%0%31'2!*31 @ 4*21 %I'3+#45H#9@I2D!5*H'#H'!C2#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5 '2!AH2-#4@+%H25I3C+I#9CAH%0B#@#5"-2DI#1#0*2#L2#*1*8I22#12'4 2 55HAH21 A!I-"9H 2"CI#-B"2"5H%I2"%61 OECD (2020) @I'H2 2-B#@#5"@G1'A#@ 4-L2#5H*31  6H*H%H-A'4142##4+2#A%02#12#I22#12'4 2 5 B#@#5"2C+ H!1!5#05H@G22#!2'H2A%0!5#1"2#5H@5"- C05HB#@#5"2@%G!16H22#*7H-*2#AD!H@G22#A%0'2!C%I 4#0+'H29I#4+2#1#9 '2!AH2@+%H25I*H%H-'452#1A%0#0*2#L-#9H-2#*1*8I22#12'4 2 5 Fullan (2016) 5I'H2 '2!*2!2#--L2#B#@#5"C2#A%2#1*4CI22##4+2#C+I%2"@G2#*1*82'4 2 55H!5'2!+!2" 6I-"9H1@7H-D@ 4B#*#I2-B#@#5" #'!62--L2#A%0'2! 1 I--2##0*22I22##4+2# 11I 2-B#@#5"6!5%D!H@5"H-'2!#I-!I2#1"2# AH"1!5%H-'452#3A'4142##4+2#DC IC 5'4#03'1 B"*#8 $)52##4+2#2#(6)2 5IC+I@+G'H2 %1)0@ 4-L2#-B#@#5"!52*31 H-#0*2#L2#12'4 2 5-#9 C##211"@+%H25I 2-B#@#5"7-@G1' 5I'15H*31 -'2!AH2CB#*#I22##4+2# 2##02"#1"2# A%0#9A4*1!1L !8!!-@ 4$)55I@G7I2*31 C2#'4@#20+L'2!AH2-2##1#9I-#9H-2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5CB#@#5"5H!52AH21C2#(6)2#1I5I 2.3.4 !8!!-2##1#9I-#9C20#-2#'4@#20+L Bandura (1986) -42"C$)52##9I42*1!'H2 $4##!-8%D!HDI93+B"11"A'%I-!B"# AH6I-"9H1'455H8%#1#9IA%05'2!11"@+%H21IC@ 4'2!4 @7H-D 2"-0!5-44%H-$4##!GH-@!7H-8%#1#9IA%0#0!'%%*4H1IA%I'@H21I !8!!-5I@I"I3'2!*31 -  2##1#9I C2#3'2!@I2C'H2 * 2A'%I-!--L2#!5%H-2#4142'4 2 5-"H2D# Eisenberger A%00 (1986) A*C+I@+GH2$)52#*1*82-L2#'H2 2##1#9I-8%3+I25H@G%D*31 5H@ 7H-!B"2#1'2@ 4*2112#-*-2$4##! A!I-L2#01C+I!5!2#2#*1*85H%I2"%61 AH'2!AH2C2##1#9I-AH%08%-23D*9H'2!AH2-#012#!5*H'#H'!A%02#@I2#H'!4##! I-I5I 5IC+I@+G'H2 2##0@!42#*1*82-L2#3@GI-42#2'H2*!2 4  #1#9I 2#*1*81I-"H2D# Skaalvik A%0 Skaalvik (2011) @I'H2 2##1#9I-#9H-* 2A'%I-!2#*1*82B#@#5"!5-44%-"H2!2H-A#9C2'4 2 5 '2!6-CC2 A%02#!5*H'#H'!C4##!2'4 2 5 2##0@!4-#9H-2#*1*82H2"#4+2#!1!5'2!*1!1L1$4##!2'4 2 5#4 !2'H2B"2"+#7-@2#!L-H2"#4+2#C@ 4#9A OECD (2019) #08'H2 2##0@!4#0*44%-2#*1*8I22#12'4 2 53@GI--2(1"A'25H"62##1#9I@G2 !8!!--#9H-'2!@GDDIC2414A%0'2!!5'2!+!2"-B-2*C2#12'4 2 5 *H%B"#H-'2!@G!CC2#!5*H'#H'!C2#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5 I-*1@5I-"I3'2!*31 -2#(6)22#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 52!8!!--#9 Fullan (2016) 5I'H2 '2!*3@#G-2#4#92#(6)2A%0B#2#12'4 2 5 6I-"9H1'455H#95'2!A%0-*-H-A'4142##4+2# +2#2(22##1#9I@ 4'2#9 A!I2#1'2@ 4*210--A!2-"H25 G-2D!H*2!2#H-C+I@4%%1L2'4 2 52!5H2+'1DI B"*#8 2'41"@+%H25IA*C+I@+G'H2  2##1#9I @G#-2#'4@#20+L5H*31 C2#3'2!@I2C'H2 A'4142##4+2#A%0@7H-D@ 4-L2#!5-44%H-2#12'4 2 5#9-"H2D# !8!!-5I@ 7H-!B"-44%- H'122#C-2 5 2#*1*82-L2# A%0%1)0-L2#-B#@#5" H22#C+I'2!*31 1'455H#9#0*A%0#0@!42#*1*8I22#12'4 2 5 6@G@+8%@ 4$)55H 1@*3+#12#3!8!!-2##1#9I-#9!2@GA+%1C2#'4@#20+L-2#(6)2#1I5I @!7H-42#2B"#'! A'42$)5@+%H25I!4DI3+I25H@G3-42"5HA"*H'21 AH#H'!1H-#9@G7I22$)5*3+#12#1@%7-1'A#C2#(6)25I $)5#0"0122#C'4 2 5 (Career Stage Theory) -42"'H23D!#95H!5#0*2#L2#*-AH216-25'2!2#*1*8I22#12'4 2 5AH21 $)52##1#9I2#*1*82-L# (Organizational Support Theory) -42"'H23D!2##1#9I-#96!5'2!*31 -"H2"4HH-'2!@I2C-44%-2##4+2# A%0$)52##4+2#2#(6)2 (Educational Management Theory) 5IC+I@+G'H2%1)0@ 4-L2#-B#@#5" B"@ 202B#@#5" !52*31 C2#3+#0*2#L2'4 2 5-#9 '2!@ 7H-!B"2$)5@+%H25I3C+I#-2#'4@#20+L-2#(6)25ID!HDI@422#@%7-1'A#B"#2(2+%12# +2AH1I-"9H7I2-$)55HDI#12#"-!#1-"H2@G#0 2.4 !8!!-2##4+2#2#(6)2C2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9 2.4.1 #02##4+2#B#@#5"12#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5 Bush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ullan (2016) 5I'H2 2#!5-"9H-#02##4+2#@5"-"H2@5"'D!HDI#1#01'H20H-C+I@4#0*2#L2#12'4 2 55H!5'2!+!2" #0*44%-#0@+%H25I6I-"9H12#3D414-"H2*!H3@*!-C4##!#03'1-B#@#5" #9!1#0@!42#*1*8I22#12'4 2 52'455H#02##4+2#32#4 !2'H22I-3+5H#2C@-*2# Hoy A%0 Miskel (2013) @*-'H2 2#3#02##4+2#DC II'"'2!*!H3@*!- H'"C+I#9@42##1#9I5H!1HH-4(2A%0%31'2!*31 --L2# @!7H-#02#12'4 2 593DC I@G#03A%022#LDI #90!5A'BI!!-2#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5'H2@G*H'+6H-'2!#14 -2'4 2 5 A5H0!-'H2@G 2#0@4H!@4! C#4-B#@#5"!1"!(6)2 #02##4+2#!52*31 "4H6I @7H-2 2#02*-5H+1A%0A#122#*- +2D!H!52#1'2@ 4*215H 1@ #9!1#0*'2!"2%32C2#*#I2*!8%#0+'H2+I25H2#*-12#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5 11I #02##4+2#63+I25H@G+%1#01@ 4B#*#I2C2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9 B"*#8 2'41"@+%H25I 5IC+I@+G'H2 #02##4+2#-B#@#5"!52C2#3+#0*2#L2#12'4 2 5-#9 H22#12#'H2 2#@#5"#9I2'4 2 591 '2%31'2!*31  A%03@4-"H2H-@7H-C4##!#03'1-B#@#5"-"H2D# !8!!-5I@IC+I@+G2-#02##4+2#C20%D7I2-2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9 2.4.2 A'414I22##4+2#1#0*2#L2#12'4 2 5-#9 Fullan (2016) 5I'H2 #0*44%-#02##4+2#B#@#5"6I-"9H1'455H#0@+%H21I9A%D*9HA'414C 5'4#03'1 #0*2#L2#12'4 2 5-#9D!HDI93+22#1'2@ 4#9A@H21I AH6I-"9H1'455H2#1*4CI22##4+2#93DC I#4C 5'4#03'1-B#@#5" A'414#03 @ H 2##02" 2#02 #9A2#*7H-*2# A%02#12#2@'%2 %I'*H%B"#H-B-2*-#9C2#!5*H'#H'!C2#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5 Hoy A%0 Miskel (2013) @I'H2 '2!*!H3@*!--A'4142##4+2#!52*31 H-2#*#I22##1#9I-*!2 4H-4(2A%0%31'2!*31 --L2# @!7H-A'4145H@5H"'I-12#12'4 2 5!5'2!!1HA%022#LDI #90!5A'BI!!-2#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5'H2@G*H'+6H-24 A5H0!-'H2@G 2#4@4H!@4! Skaalvik A%0 Skaalvik (2011) 'H2 2##1#9I-#9H-'2!@2#A%02#*1*8CA'4142##4+2#!5'2!*1!1L-"H2C%I 41A#9CA%02#!5*H'#H'!2'4 2 5 #9!1#0@!42#*1*8I22#12'4 2 5H22##03@ 4414-H2"#4+2# @ H 2#1*##@'%2-"H2@5"-*3+#14##!2#@#5"#9I A%02#"-!#1'2!"2"2!2'4 2 5-#9 Bush (2011) 5I'H2 #9A2##4+2#"1!5-44%H-'455H#9#0*12#*1*8I22#12'4 2 5 A'4142##4+2#5H@I2#*1*8 6HC+I'2!*31 1'2!I-2#-#9A%02#*H@*#4!'2!@G-4*#02'4 2 5 !5A'BI!5H0H-C+I@4#0*2#L2#12'4 2 5@ 4' !2'H22##4+2#5H@I2#'8!A%0%%1LI2#0*44 2@G+%1 C#4-B#@#5"!1"!(6)2 A'4142##4+2#C 5'4#03'1!5%5H@+GDI 1@"4H6I @7H-2#9!5 2#02*-5H+1 +2A'4142##4+2#D!H366 2#02A%0'2!I-2#2'4 2 5-#9 #9-2!-4##!2#12'4 2 5'H2@G 2#0 C2%11 @!7H-A'4142##4+2#*2!2#@ 7H-!B"2#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5@I212*-#03'1 #90!5A'BI!#0@!42#*1*8I22#12'4 2 5C@ 4'!26I B"*#8 2'41"@+%H25I 5IC+I@+G'H2 A'4142##4+2#@G%D*31 5H3C+I#0@ 4*21*H%H-#0*2#L2#12'4 2 5-#9 2##1#9I-#9H-2#*1*8I22#12'4 2 5693+-"H2!22'455H2#1*4CI22##4+2#93D414#4C 5'4#03'1-B#@#5" 2.4.3 2'09I3-B#@#5"12#*1*82#12'4 2 5 Hallinger (2011) 5I'H2 9I#4+2#*2(6)2!5-44%H-2#12'4 2 5-#9@G+%1H22#3+%31'2!*31 --L2#A%04(22#1*###1"2# $4##!-9I3-2D!HDI@5H"'I-B"#14##!6-#!2'4 2 5 AH*2!2#*H*1  25H 1@6'2!*31 -2#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5 2"CB#@#5" Leithwood A%00 (2019) @I'H2 A'414I2 2'09I3!5*H'*31 C2#*#I2##"22(-B#@#5"5H@-7I-H-+#7-312#@4B2'4 2 5-#9 @!7H-9I3A*'2!C*HCH-'2!I-2#2'4 2 5-#9-"H2H-@7H- #90!5A'BI!!-2#12'4 2 5'H2@G*H'5H!58H2C2- A5H0@GI-3+2 2"- OECD (2020) 5I'H2 2#*1*82#12'4 2 529I3!1*0I-H22##035H@+GDI 1 @ H 2#3+'2#02##0 8! 2#@I2#H'!4##!2#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5 A%02#-*-H-I-1'%I22#12-#9 #9!15'2!2##03@+%H25I'H2@G+%12-'2!!8H!1H5HAI#4-H2"#4+2#H-2#12'4 2 5 Skaalvik A%0 Skaalvik (2011) 'H2 2##1#9I-#9H-2#*1*829I3!5'2!*1!1L-"H2!21'2!@G!CC2#!5*H'#H'!C2#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5 A!I0!5#02#12'4 2 55H@G22#-"9HA%I' AH+29I3D!HDIC+I'2!*31 -"H2@5"- 2##0@!4B"#'!-#9H-2#*1*8G-2%%DI Bush (2011) @+G'H2 $4##!-9I33+I25H@G*02@ 7H-!#0+'H22#1'2@ 4*211#0*2#L#4-#9 #9D!HDI#0@!48H2-2#*1*8I22#12'4 2 52B"2"5H@G%2"%1)L-1)#@5"-"H2@5"' AH22##03C 5'4#03'1 2#*7H-*2# A%0%31'2!*31 5H9I3A*-- C#4-B#@#5"!1"!(6)2 -44%- 2'09I3!5'2!*31 "4H6I @7H-2I-@ 4 1'2!I-2#5HAH11#0+'H2%*1!$4L22#@#5"12#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5 @!7H-9I3C+I2#*1*8-"H2*!H3@*!-C2##0*2@'%2 %A#1I2 2#02 A%0*H@*#4!2#!5*H'#H'!2'4 2 5 #90!5A'BI!#1#9I2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5C@ 4'!26I B"*#8 2'41"@+%H25I 5IC+I@+G'H2 $4##!-9I3@G11"*31 5H3+'455H#9#0*A%0#0@!42#*1*8I22#12'4 2 5 2##03-9I33C+I@2#!LI22##4+2#9A%@GA'4145H!-@+GDI 6H*H%B"#H-#0*2#L2#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5-#9 2.4.4 2#1*###1"2# 2#1@'%2 A%0'2!@G##! OECD (2019) @I'H2 2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9-"H2!5#0*44%6I-"9H1'H2B#@#5"*2!2#12#*1*8I2#1"2#A%0@'%2DI-"H2"1H"7+#7-D!H 2#@I26B-2*C2#-#! *7H-2#@#5"#9I A%04##!2'4 2 5 6I-"9H1'455HB#@#5"1*###1"2#A%01@'%2C+I#9!5*H'#H'!C2#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5 Adams (1965) @*-$)5'2!"84##! (Equity Theory) B"-42"'H2 8%0#0@!42#*1*82-L2#H22#@#5"@5"'2!@G##!C2##02"#1"2#A%0B-2*#0+'H2*!2 4 C#4-2#12'4 2 5 #9!142#2'H2B-2*C2#-#!A%02#@#5"#9I91*##-"H2@G##!2!@L5H 1@+#7-D!H 2##1#9I6'2!"84##!!5-44%H-2##0@!4B"#'!-#9H-2#*1*8I22#12'4 2 5 Hargreaves (2019) 5I'H2 C* 2A'%I-!22#(6)25H!5 2#02+1A%0A#1I2%*1!$4L @'%2-2!5-44%H-#0*2#L2#12'4 2 5-#9!2'H22#*1*8I2#1"2# +2D!H!52#1@'%2-"H2 1@*3+#12#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5 #9-2!-4##!@+%H25I'H2@G 2#0@4H!@4!!2'H20@G2#*1*85H!5'2!+!2" Skaalvik A%0 Skaalvik (2011) 'H2 2##1#9I-#9H-'2!@G##!CA'4142##4+2#!5'2!*1!1L-"H2C%I 41'2!D'I'2CH--L2#A%0A#9C2'4 2 5 @!7H-#9#1#9I'H22##02"B-2*D!H@H2@5"! +#7-@L2#@I2#H'!D!H 1@ 2##0@!4-#9H-2#*1*8I22#12'4 2 5!1%% Fullan (2016) 5I'H2 2#1*###1"2#A%02#1@'%2@G%D@ 44145H3C+I@2#!LI22##4+2#9A%@G#0*2#L#4-#9 A!I#02#12'4 2 50DI#12#--A!2-"H25 AH+2#9#1#9I'H2!5@'%231+#7-2#1*###1"2#D!H@G##! G-23C+I%%1L5H2+'1D!H@46I C#4-B#@#5"!1"!(6)2 2##1#9I@#7H-'2!@G##!!5'2!-H-D+'@G4@() @7H-2'2!AH2- 2#02A%0'2!#14 -2!#2"'4 2 #9!1@#5"@5"B-2*C2#12'4 2 5#0+'H2%8H!*2#0A%0#01 1I 2#@#5"@5"@+%H25I!5-44%H-2##0@!4-#9H-#012#*1*8I22#12'4 2 52B#@#5" B"*#8 2'41"@+%H25I 5IC+I@+G'H2 2#1*###1"2# 2#1@'%2 A%0'2!@G##! @G11"*31 5H3+2##1#9I-#9H-2#*1*8I22#12'4 2 5 2##0@!4-#9D!HDI6I-"9H@5"'H2!5B-2*+#7-D!H AH6I-"9H1'455HB-2*@+%H21I91*##A%03+@'%2C2#414#4 2.4.5 '2!AH2-2B#@#5"12#*1*82#12'4 2 5 Hoy A%0 Miskel (2013) 5I'H2 2-B#@#5"@G%1)0@ 4-L2#5H*31  6H!5-44%H-B#*#I22##4+2# #9A2#*7H-*2# A%02##02"#1"2# 2"CB#@#5" '2!AH2-2B#@#5"!13D*9H'2!AH2C'452#12#A'414I22##4+2# A%0'455H#9#0*12#*1*82'4 2 5 Bush (2011) @*-'H2 B#@#5"2@%G!1!5B#*#I2-L2#5HD!H 1 I- A%0!5'2!C%I 4#0+'H2#919I#4+2# C#4@ H5I 2#*1*8I22#12'4 2 5!19#1#9IH22#*7H-*2#AD!H@G22#A%0'2!C*HCB"#2H2"#4+2# %1)01%H2'-2*H%H-2##1#9I-#9H-2#*1*8C%1)05HAH22B#@#5"2C+ H OECD (2020) #08'H2 B#@#5"2C+ H!1!5#05H@G22#!2'H2A%0!5#1"2#I22#12'4 2 5!2'H2 -"H2D#G2! '2! 1 I--B#*#I22##4+2#CB#@#5"2C+ H-2%B-2*C2#C+I2#*1*8A@ 208%A%02#*7H-*2#B"##0+'H2#919I#4+2# '2! 1 I-@ 4-L2#5I-2!5%H-'455H#9#1#9I2#12#I22#12'4 2 5 Fullan (2016) 5I'H2 '2!*2!2#-B#@#5"C2#A%2#1*4CI22##4+2#C+I%2"@G2#*1*82'4 2 55H!5'2!+!2" 6I-"9H2*H'1@7H-D@ 4B#*#I2--L2# #'!62-B#@#5"A%0%D2##0*22 2-B#@#5"6!5%D!H@5"H-'2!#I-!I2#1"2# AH"1*H%H-'452#3A'4142##4+2#DC IC 5'4#03'1 Leithwood A%00 (2019) @I'H2 #4@ 4-L2#3+#0*2#L-#9H-2#*1*82'4 2 5 #95H32CB#@#5"5H!52AH21-25'2!2#12#I22#12'4 2 55H%I2"%61AH21 @7H-2#9A4*1!1L '2!@I269I#4+2# A%02##0*22C-L2#5HAH21 B"*#8 2'41"@+%H25I 5IC+I@+G'H2 2-B#@#5"@G11"#4*31 5H!5-44%H-'455H#9#0*1#02##4+2# $4##! 2'09I3 A%02#1*###1"2# '2!AH2-2B#@#5"6*H%H-'2!AH2C2##1#9I-#9H-2#*1*8I22#12'4 2 5 !8!!-5I@G7I2C2#'4@#20+L2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5CB#@#5"5H!52AH21C2#(6)2#1I5I OECD (2020) 5IC+I@+G'H2 '2!AH2-2B#@#5"*H%H-'455H#9#1#9IA%0#0*1A'414I22##4+2# CB#@#5"2@%G '2!C%I 4-'2!*1!1L#0+'H28%-23C+I#9#1#9I62#*1*85H!5%1)0@ 208%!26I 05HCB#@#5"2C+ H #05H@G22#-2@4B-2*C+I!52#12-"H2@G#0!2'H2 AH%1!5'2!@-2CC*H#2"8%I-"% 2.5 2#3+3A+H2#'41"A%0#-2#'4@#20+L-2#(6)25I 2.5.1 2#3+3A+H@ 4$)5-2#(6)25I Bush (2011) A%0 Hoy and Miskel (2013) @I'H2 #22#L22#(6)25H@46ICB#@#5"'#9'4@#20+L 2"CI#---L2#B#@#5" !2'H22#!-'H2@G$4##!*H'8%5HA"2--2#4 4##!2'4 2 5-#9 #'!62#12'4 2 5 %I'1-"9HCB#*#I22##4+2# 2#1'2@ 4*21 A%0'1##!-L2# !8!!-5I@G7I2*31 5H3C+I2#(6)25I1I-"9HC*222##4+2#2#(6)2 A5H0!-2#12'4 2 5#9@G@5"#0'2#@#5"#9I-1@8% Darling-Hammond A%00 (2017) A%0 OECD (2019) A*C+I@+G'H22#12'4 2 5#99@I2C!26IC20#0'2#5HH-@7H-A%01-"9HC#4 6HDI#1-44%2* 2A'%I-!-B#@#5" A!I2'41"@+%H25I0C+I!8!!-2$)55H!58H2 AH23'!2"1!8H@I#9A2#@#5"#9I5H!5#0*44%A%02#12#C#01#0 B"C+I'2!*31 I-"H-'455H#9#1#9IA%0#0*12#*1*81%H2'C 5'42#32#03'1-B#@#5" Gu Mingyuan (2016) A%0 Zhong Binglin (2017) 5I'H22'41"-5!5*H'*31 C2#3'2!@I2C#-@ 4*21A%02#3@4B"2"5H@5H"'I-12#12'4 2 5#9 -"H2D#G2! 2'41"3'!2@I2#--A#0A%0%D2#6-#! !2'H22#*3#''H22#*1*8@ 4*21@+%H25I9A#D@G#0*2#L2'4 2 5-#9C#4B#@#5"-"H2D# Skaalvik A%0 Skaalvik (2011) A%0 Eisenberger A%00 (1986) 5IC+I@+G'H22#*1*82-L2#!5-44%H-$4##!2'4 2 5H2  2##1#9I -8%@G*31  2#-*--#9H-A'414I22##4+2#D!HDI6I-"9H1@5"2#!5-"9H-!2#2#*1*8 AH6I-"9H1'455H#95'2!A%0#0@!4!2#2#@+%H21I !8!!-5I 5I'H22#C IA'25H@I2##1#9I@G*4H3@GC2#3'2!@I2C'H22#*1*82#12'4 2 53@4D-"H2D#C2414 Huberman (1989) A%0 Day (2017) @I'H2'2!I-2#2'4 2 5-#9AH21D2! H'122#C'4 2 5 #9CAH%0 H'-'# 5'42'4 2 5!5'2!2+'1A%0%31'2!*31 5HAH21 6H*H%H-2#-*-H-B-2*C2#12'4 2 5 !8!!-2$)55I 5I'H22#(6)22#12'4 2 5#9B"D!H3665#0*2#L2#*- -2!-I2!'2!AH25H*31 C#0*2#L2'4 2 5 OECD (2020) A%0 Fullan (2016) 5I'H2@7H-D@ 4-L2#-B#@#5" #'!6%1)0B#*#I2 @ H 2B#@#5" !5-44%H-A'414I22##4+2# 2#1*###1"2# A%0#9A4*1!1L 2"CB#@#5" '2!AH2@ 4-L2#@+%H25I*H%H-'455H2#*1*82#12'4 2 593D414A%09#1#9IB"#9 6H 5I'H2'2!AH2-2B#@#5"-23D*9H'2!AH2C2##1#9I2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5 2#'2'41"1IC#0122 24 5 A%0D" A*C+I@+G'H22'41"5H!5-"9H!1(6)22#12'4 2 5#92!8!!-@ 4B"2" +#7-!8!!-I2#0*44%-B#2# 05H2'41"5H9#22#%1)0 H'122#-#9 @7H-D@ 4-L2#-B#@#5" A%02##1#9I-#9 @I2D'IC#-2#'4@#20+L@5"'1"1!5I-" I-315I3C+I2'41"H-+I2-42"DID!H@5"-'H2A'414I22##4+2#!5-44%H-#0*2#L2#12'4 2 5-#9C#4B#@#5"@ 20-"H2D# 22#42#22$)51%H2' 2#(6)25I6'23A+H@--"9H!8!!--2##4+2#2#(6)2 B"@I4*1!1L#0+'H2@7H-D@ 4-L2#-B#@#5"12##1#9I2'4 2 5-#9 A5H0#0@!4B#2#12'4 2 5+#7-2#--AB"2" 2#(6)25I!8H@I'H22#12'4 2 59  *H@*#4! 2"CB#@#5"-"H2D# A%0#9#1#9I2#*H@*#4!1I-"H2D#C 5'42#32#03'1 %H2'C+I 1@"4H6I 2#(6)25I!-2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9'H2@G%*0I--A'414I22##4+2# 2#1'2@ 4*21 A%02#*1*8@ 4-L2# #9D!HDI9!-@5"C209I@I2#H'!4##!12'4 2 5 AH"1@G9I#0@!4#0*44%-2#*1*822##4+2#I'" 2##1#9I-#96C+II-!9%5H!5'2!+!2"@5H"'12#32-2#*1*82#12'4 2 5C2414 -25I 2#(6)25I"19#22#11"@ 4#45H*31 *-#02# DIAH 5#0*2#L2#*--#9 A%02B#@#5" 5#0*2#L2#*-C IA'2!AH2C H'122#A%0%31'2!*31 2'4 2 5-#9 05H2B#@#5"*0I-'2!AH2C@7H-D@ 4-L2#A%0B#*#I22##4+2# 2#*211"@+%H25I@I21#-2#'4@#20+L5H@I2##1#9I H'"C+I@4'2!@I2C5H#-%8!!26I@5H"'12#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5C#4B#@#5"!1"!(6)2 2#!8H@ID5HB#@#5"!1"!(6)2"1 H'"@*#4!'2!AGA#2$)5-2#(6)25I @7H-2B#@#5"!1"!(6)23@42 2"CIA#1I22#*- '2!@ 202-#2"'4 2 A%0%31'2!*31 I22##4+2#5H@I%2#*- #4@+%H25I3C+I%-A'414I22##4+2#H-2#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5-#9#2 1@@G4@() 2##1#9I-#9C* 2A'%I-!@ H5I6@G+%125H!58H2*3+#13'2!@I2C'H22#*1*82#12'4 2 532-"H2D# 2"CII-31@ 4-L2##4 11I 2#(6)25ID!HDI!8H*#I2A3%-$)5C+!H@5H"'12#12'4 2 5#9 AHC I$)55H!5-"9HA%I'CI22##4+2#2#(6)2 2#*1*8@ 4-L2# A%0$)5 H'122#'4 2 5 !2'4@#20+L'H22#12'4 2 59*H@*#4!A%09#1#9I-"H2D#C#4B#@#5"!1"!(6)2@ 4 9!4 25H@ 20@20 2#'23A+H@ H5I3C+I2#(6)2!5'2!!1H2$)5 #I-!1I"1!5'2!@5H"'I-@ 4414H-2##4+2#B#@#5"A%0B"2"2#12#9-"H2 1@ 2.5.2 #-2#'4@#20+LA%01'A#2#'41" Bush (2011) A%0 Hoy and Miskel (2013) @I'H24##!2'4 2 5-#9'#9'4@#20+L 2"CIB#*#I2-L2#A%0A'414I22##4+2#-B#@#5" 2#12'4 2 56D!HC H4##!5HA"2 AH93+B"'455HB#@#5"1#0@5"2 1*###1"2# A%03+%31'2!*31 @ 4*21 !8!!-5I@G2@ 4-L2#*3+#12#*#I2#-2#'4@#20+L-2#(6)25I Eisenberger A%00 (1986) A%0 Skaalvik A%0 Skaalvik (2011) A*C+I@+G'H2-44%--L2#3@4H2  2##1#9I -8%@G*31  2#-*-2'4 2 5-#9D!HDI6I-"9H@5"2#!5-"9H-!2#2##4+2# AH6I-"9H1'455H#9#0*A%0#0@!4!2#2#@+%H21I I-I2$)55I*1*82#C I2##1#9I-#9@G'45+%1C2#'12#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9 Huberman (1989) A%0 Day (2017) 5I'H2'2!1'%A%0%31'2!*31 2'4 2 5-#9AH212! H'122#C-2 5 #9CAH%0 H' 5'4'4 2 5-2#0@!42#*1*8@5"'1H21 !8!!-5I@G2*3+#12#3  5#0*2#L2#*- !2@G1'A#-4*#0C#-2#'4@#20+L OECD (2020) A%0 Fullan (2016) 5I'H2%1)0@ 4-L2# B"@ 20  2B#@#5" !5-44%H-A'414I22##4+2# #9A2#*7H-*2# A%02##0*2#1"2# '2!AH2@+%H25I*H%H-'455H#9#0*2#*1*82#12'4 2 5 6@G@+8%C2#3  2B#@#5" !2@G1'A#-4*#0*31 -51' 22$)51%H2' #-2#'4@#20+L-2#(6)25I6*21'A#-4*#0*-1' DIAH 5#0*2#L2#*- A%02B#@#5" @I211'A#2!+6H1' 7- #012#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#92!2##1#9I-#9 #-5I@I4*1!1L#0+'H2%1)02'4 2 5-#91@7H-D@ 4-L2#-B#@#5"C2#3+#0*2#L2#12'4 2 5 C2'41"5I 5#0*2#L2#*-C I@G1'H 5I H'122#'4 2 5-#9 B"1%8H!2!#0"0@'%22#*-@7H-*0I-'2!AH2I2%31'2!*31 A%0'2!2+'12'4 2 5 2#1%8H!5I@-7I-C+I@42#@#5"@5"2##1#9I2#*1*8#0+'H2#9C H'-2 55HH21 2B#@#5"C I@G1'H 5I@7H-D@ 4-L2# '2!AH2-3'#9*0I-'2! 1 I-I22##4+2# #9A2#*7H-*2# A%0'2!#I-!I2#1"2# 2#@#5"@5"#92B#@#5"H22 H'"C+I@+G-44%-2-L2#H-2##1#9I2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5 1'A#2! 7- 2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9 94"2!@ 44142#H22##1#9I-#9H-2#*1*8C#01B#@#5" A2#!8H5HB#2#6-#!+#7-@-*2#B"2"@ 20 2#4"2!@ H5I*-%I-1!8!!-5H@I2##1#9I-#92!2$)5 @7H-'11'A#2!5I 2#(6)23 4 !445H*1@#20+L2$)52#12'4 2 5#9A%0A'4I22##4+2#2#(6)2 !445H+6H 2#12'2!#9I'4 2 5 *0I-'H2B#@#5"12#6-#!-"H2@G#0 *#I2##"22(-L2#A+H2#@#5"#9I A%0!5A12'4 2 55H 1@-"H2D# !445H*- 1)0A%02#414'4 2 5 42#22#*1*84##!12'4 2 5CB#@#5" '2!#H'!!7-#0+'H2@7H-#9 2#3 Lesson Study A%02#*0I-2#*- !445H*2! 1(4A%0-1%1)L'4 2 5 !8H5H2#"-!#129I#4+2# '2!"84##!-#0#0@!4 A%0'2! 1@-@*I2'2!I2'+I2C-2 5 !445H*5H 2#*1*8@ 4-L2#A%0@ 4*21 #0@!42#1B"2" @'%2 #1"2# A%0A#9C@7H-2#12'4 2 5 1I*5H!445I*-%I-B"#12#- 4#2"@ 4$)5CH-+I2 A%0#H'!1*0I-'H2#0#4+2# A'414#03'1 2'09I3 A%0@7H-D@ 4-L2# 3+#0*2#L2#12'4 2 5-#9-"H2D# 2#9#22#!44@+%H25IC#-2#'15H@I2##1#9I 3C+I2#(6)2*2!2#*0I-#0*2#L-#9H-2#*1*82#12'4 2 5DI-"H2#-%8! A%0@-7I-C+I@42#@#5"@5"-"H2@G#0#0+'H2%8H!#92!5#0*2#LA%02B#@#5" #-2#'4@#20+L5I6@ 7H-!B"-"H2*-%I-#0+'H22$)5 1'A#'41" A%02#--A@#7H-!7-'1 A%0@G7I25H 1@*3+#12#'4@#20+L@ 4#01)LC5H 3 B"1I-"9H$)5I22##4+2#2#(6)2 2#*1*8@ 4-L2# A%0$)5 H'122#'4 2 5-"H2!1H 2.6 #4B#@#5"!1"!(6)2A%0'2! 1 I-@ 4414C2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9 #0#'(6)242#-5 (2020) @I'H2 2#(6)2#01!1"!(6)2!52 5I2H-'2!I2'+I22'4 22#-9I@#5" A%0@ 7H-!B"-"H2C%I 41#0 Gaokao C202#*-#01 245H!5'2!*31 *9 Gaokao D!H@5"3+%31'2!*31 I22#*- AH"13+##02##4+2#B#@#5"I'" B#@#5"!1"!63@42 2"CIA#1I2%*1!$4L-"H2H-@7H- 6H%2#*-*1!1L1 7H-@*5" 2##0@!4 A%02#1*###1"2#-B#@#5" #45I3C+I2#03'1-#9!8H@ID5H%2#*-@G*31  Hargreaves (2019) 5I'H2 C* 2A'%I-!2#(6)25H!5A#1I2'2!#14 -*9 #9!1@ 4 '2!6@#5"#0+'H2 2#02#*-1B-2*C2#@#5"#9I@ 4'4 2 5 CB#@#5"!1"! #9I-C I@'%2-"H2!212#@#5"!@#5" 2#A0A'@7H-2#*- A%02#42!%2#@#5"-1@#5" 2"CI@7H-D1%H2' 4##!12'4 2 5-29!-'H2  AH1 1 2#02#*- !2'H20@G*4H5H*1*82#*- Fullan (2016) 5I'H2 '2!*3@#G-2#*1*82#12'4 2 56I-"9H12#5H2##4+2#12#*2!2#-B"LI-31@ 44145H#9@ 4 DI+#7-D!H C#4B#@#5"!1"! 2#1*4CI22#1@'%2 2##02" 2#02 A%02#1%31'2!*31 -2 *H%B"#H-'2!@GDDI5H#90!5*H'#H'!C4##!2#@#5"#9I2'4 2 5 OECD (2019) @I'H2  @'%2 @G@7H-D*31 -2#!5*H'#H'!C2#12'4 2 5 CB#@#5"!1"!5H2#2*-AHA%02#@#5"!*-H-@7H- A!I0!5B#2#125H--A!2-"H25 G-2!5%31 +2#9D!H!5@'%2@5"-5H0!5*H'#H'!-"H2!5'2!+!2" Huberman (1989) @*-'H2 #9C H'122#-2 55HH21-*-H-A#1@ 4#4H21 #9 H'I-2 5CB#@#5"!1"!!1#0*'2!"2%32C2#*!8%#0+'H22#12# 1I@#5" 2#*-#2"'4 2 A%02#@#5"#9I'4 2 5 05H#95H!5#0*2#L!2-2I-#14 -H-%2#*-A%025H@%5I" A#1@+%H25I!5%H-'455H#9#0@!42#*1*82#12'4 2 5 Hoy A%0 Miskel (2013) 5I'H2  '2!@ 5H"' 2 #2"'4 2 @G%1)0*31 -B#@#5"!1"! #9AH%0%8H!*2#0@ 4 '2!I-2#I22#*-A%0#9A2##0@!45HH21 2#112'4 2 5A@5"'1-2D!H-B"L'2!I-2#@ 20#2"'4 2 3C+I#9#0@!42#*1*8AH212!'2!*-%I-1#42#*-- Bush (2011) @I'H2 %31'2!*31 I22##4+2#!5%H-2#'23A+H-2#12'4 2 5C2B#@#5" C* 2A'%I-!5H@I Gaokao 2#1*4CI22##4+2#!1C+I'2!*31 12#@#5"!*- 4##!125HD!H9!-'H2@ 7H-!B"B"#1%2#*- -2DI#1'2!*31 I-"'H2C2414 Skaalvik A%0 Skaalvik (2011) 'H2 2##1#9I2#*1*822##4+2#-#9!5'2!-H-D+'@G4@()C* 2A'%I-!5H!5A#1*9 +2#9#9I*6'H22#112'4 2 5D!H366'2!@G#4-2#*- 2##0@!42#*1*8G!5A'BI!%% A!I'H20!5B-2*@ 4#9AC+I@I2#H'! Leithwood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uskey (2002, +I2 & & ) #0-I'" 4 I2 7- 1) 2#12'2!#9I2'4 2 5 2) 1)0A%02#4142'4 2 5 3) 1(4A%0-1%1)L2'4 2 5 4) 2#*1*8@ 4-L#A%0@ 4*21 1A 9!45H 2.1 1'A#I 1'A#2!   A 9!45H 2.1 #-A'42#'41" 5H 3 '453@42#'41" za2#'41"#1I5I9I'41"!8H(6)2@7H-(6)22##4+2#12#+I-*!82!!8!!---22#"L!+2'4"2%1"@BB%"5-2 5'(6)2+%4+4@7H-@#5"@5"2##4+2#12#+I-*!82!!8!!---22#"L!+2'4"2%1"@BB%"5-2 5'(6)2+%4+43A2!@(A%0#0*2#L32 !5A'2C2#'41"2!1I-15I 1.#0 2#A%0%8H!1'-"H2 2.@#7H-!7-5HC IC2#'41" 3.2#*#I2@#7H-!7-5HC IC2#'41" 4.2#@G#'#'!I-!9% 5.2#'4@#20+LI-!9% 6.*445HC IC2#'4@#20+LI-!9% #0 2#A%0%8H!1'-"H2 #0 2#5HC IC2#'41" 7- #9!1"!(6)2C@@!7- 2 8 !%5K+%4 3' 475  2*2(6)2 3' 6 A+H (Changchun No.1 Secondary School, Jilin Provincial Experimental Secondary School, Changchun Jiu tai Experimental Secondary School, Changchun Yang zheng Secondary School, Affiliated Secondary School of Northeast Normal University, Changchun Wen li Secondary School) 52#(6)2 2566 %8H!1'-"H25HC IC2#'41" 7- #9!1"!(6)2C@@!7- 2 8 !%5K+%4 3' 210  3+2-%8H!1'-"H2B"C I2#2- Krejcie & Morgan (1970) 5H#01'2!@ 7H-!1H#I-"%0 95 B"2#*8H!1'-"H2-"H2H2" (Simple Random Sampling) #2"%0@-5"A*C2#25H 3.1 15I 2#25H 3.1 3'#0 2#A%0%8H!1'-"H2 *2(6)2#0 2# 9I#4+2##0 2# #9#'!%8H!1'-"H2 9I#4+2#%8H!1'-"H2 #9#'!Changchun No.1 Secondary School-9595-42Jilin Provincial Experimental Secondary School-8888-39Changchun Jiu tai Experimental Secondary School-7575-33Changchun Yang Zheng Secondary School-7070--31Affiliated Secondary School of Northeast Normal University-8282-36Changchun Wenli Secondary School-6565-29#'!-475475-210210 (@'GD L-"H2@G22#-B#@#5"!1"!(6)2 2 85H 1, 2025; @'GD L-"H2@G22#-B#@#5"!1"!(6)2%-!%5K+%4, 2025; @'GD L-"H2@G22#-B#@#5"!1"!(6)2%-4H'D 2 8, 2025; @'GD L-"H2@G22#-B#@#5"!1"!(6)2+"2@4I 2 8, 2025; @'GD L-"H2@G22#-B#@#5"!1"!(6)2C*11!+2'4"2%1"#9 20'1--@ 5"@+7-, 2025; B#@#5"!1"!(6)2@+'4%5H 2 8, 2025) @#7H-!7-5HC IC2#'41" @#7H-!7-5HC IC2#(6)2#1I5I7-A*-2!A*-2!5I#0-I'"*-*H': *H'5H1:A*-2!@5H"'1I-!9%1H'D-9I-A*-2!3A2!@(A%0#0*2#L32 *H'5H2:A*-2!*3+#1#'#'!'2!4@+G--22#"L@5H"'12##4+2#12#-!+2'4"2%1"@BB%"5-2 5'(6)2+%4+4C3I2DIAH1)2#12#@ 4*212)2#12#@ 4#4+2#A%03)2#12##42#2'4 22#/'4 2 5A*-2!5I93+C+I@G!2#'1AC+I0A(rating scale)B"Likert(1967)AH#010A--@G5#0115I: 5+!2"6#012#414C#01*95H*8 4+!2"6#012#414C#01*9!2 3+!2"6#012#414C#012%2 2+!2"6#012#414C#01H3 1+!2"6#012#414C#01H35H*8 2#*#I2@#7H-!7-5HC IC2#'41" 1. 2#(6)25IDI--AA*-2!2##1#9IB"C I!2#2*H'%4@4#L 5 #01 @7H-'12##1#9I-#9 2. !52#'A'4 $)5 A%02'41"@ 4#01)L5H@5H"'I-12#12'4 2 5#9A%02#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5C#42##4+2#2#(6)2 A%03!2#0"8LC IC2#--AA*-2! 3. 13A*-2! 1#H2A%03@*-H--22#"L5H#6)2@7H--3A03 21I#1#8AID2!I-@*-A05HDI#1 4. A*-2! 1#H29*HC+I9I#8'84#'*-'2!#@ 4@7I-+2 9I#8'84*2!H2DI42#2'2!*-%I-#0+'H2AH%0I-32!1'18#0*L2#'41" B"I-32!5H!5H2 IOC (Index of Item-Objective Congruence) -"9H#0+'H2 0.67 6 1.00 DI#12#1@%7-D'I A*-2!DI#12##'*-H2 IOC B"9I#8'84*2!H2 15I: 1)(2*#22#"L Guo Feijun !+2'4"2%1"#9 2 8 (2*#22#"LA%0-22#"L5H#6)2#01#4  2B 1813#3A+H9I-3'"2#*21'41"2#-8!(6)2 2)(2*#22#"L Cao Yanling !+2'4"2%1"#9 20'1--@ 5"@+7- 3)#-(2*#22#"L Zhou Da 0(6)2(2*#L !+2'4"2%1"#9 20'1--@ 5"@+7- 5. A*-2!5HDI#12##1#82!I-@*-A0-9I#8'84DI3D%-C I1%8H!5HD!HC H%8H!1'-"H23' 30  @7H-#'*-'2!@ 7H-!1H B"C IH2*1!#0*44LA-%2-#-2 (Cronbach s Alpha) 2!A'4- Cronbach (1990) %2#'4@#20+L'H2A*-2!1I 1!5H2'2!@ 7H-!1H@H21 0.89 6. 3A*-2! 1#1#8DC I@G#'#'!I-!9%#41%8H!1'-"H21I+! 2#@G#'#'!I-!9% I-!9%2#'41"9#'#'!B"2#AA*-2!C+IAHB#@#5"A%0#1A*-2!7I'"@- #2"%0@-5"-#0'2#@G#'#'!I-!9%!515I: 1)!52#"7H+1*7--'2!#H'!!7-D"1H2"#4+2#-B#@#5"!1"!(6)2 2 8+!2"@% 1 B#@#5"!1"!(6)2%-!%5K+%4 B#@#5"!1"!(6)2 2 8+!2"@% 2 A%0B#@#5"!1"!(6)2 2 8+!2"@% 11 @7H--'2!#H'!!7-C2#@G#'#'!I-!9% 2)DI#1-8 2C+I3@42#@GI-!9% 21I9I'41"DIAA*-2!C+IAH#9CB#@#5"5H@I2#H'!2#'41" !52#AA*-2!1I+! 175 1C+IAHB#@#5"!1"!(6)2C# 2 8 B"3+2#2@'%2AA%0#17 2"C*12+L1D 3)A*-2!5HDI#1793D'4@#20+LI-!9%2*44I'"B#A#!*44!2#22-!4'@-#L 2#'4@#20+LI-!9% 2#@G#'#'!I-!9% 2'41"5I@G#'#'!I-!9%B"2#*HA*-2!D"1*2(6)2A%0#17I'"@- #2"%0@-5"-#0'2#@GI-!9%!515I: 1) #'*-'2!*!9#L-A*-2! 2) C*H'5H+6H-A*-2! I-!9%1H'D-9I-A*-2!3@*-C#9A2#2#I-"%02!2#AA'2!5H 3) C*H'5H*--A*-2! C IH2#I-"%0 H2@ %5H" A%0*H'@5H"@!2#2C2#'4@#20+LI-!9% #I-!-42"2#2%%1LA%0'4@#20+L11"5H*H%H-#01#0*44 2H22#@#5"@5" #01H2@ %5H"-2##0@!4!515I: 4.50 5.00 +!2"6 2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9-"9HC#01*95H*8 3.50 4.49 +!2"6 2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9-"9HC#01*9 2.50 3.49 +!2"6 2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9-"9HC#012%2 1.50 2.49 +!2"6 2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9-"9HC#01H3 1.00 1.49 +!2"6 2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9-"9HC#01H35H*8 4) @7H-@#5"@5"2##1#9I-#9!1"!(6)2@5H"'12#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9C# 2 8 !%5K+%4 3A2!#0*2#L2#*-A%02B#@#5" B"C I2#*-H2 t (t-test) 5) @7H-@#5"@5"2##1#9I3A2!2B#@#5" C I2#'4@#20+L'2!A##'2@5"' (One-way ANOVA) A%0+2%2#'4@#20+L'2!AH2-"H2!51"*31 2*44 032#*-#2"9H 2"+%1 (@ H '45-@ @H  Scheffe s test) @7H-#08'2!AH2#0+'H2%8H!2B#@#5"H2 F *445HC IC2#'4@#20+LI-!9% C2#'4@#20+LI-!9% 9I'41"DIC I'452#2*44 1H-D5I: 1)'2!5H (Frequency) 2)#I-"%0 (Percentage) 3)H2@ %5H" (Mean) 4)*H'@5H"@!2#2 (Standard Deviation) 5)2#*- t-test A-4*#0 (Independent t-test) @-*2#-I2-4 (2011).TeacherprofessionaldevelopmentinTeachingandTeacherEducationovertenyears.TeachingandTeacherEducation,27(1),10 20.London,UK. Bush.(2011).Theoriesofeducationalleadershipandmanagement(4thed.).Sage.London,UK. Bush.(2016).SchoolleadershipandmanagementinChina:Exploringtheimpactofcontext.Routledge.London,UK. Darling-Hammond,Hyler,&Gardner.(2017).Effectiveteacherprofessionaldevelopment.LearningPolicyInstitute.PaloAlto,USA. Day.(2017).Teachers worldsandwork:Understandingcomplexity,buildingquality.Routledge.London,UK. Guskey.(2002).Professionaldevelopmentandteacherchange.TeachersandTeaching:TheoryandPractice,8(3),381 391.London,UK. GuMingyuan.(2016).TeacherdevelopmentundereducationalreforminChina.ChineseEducation&Society,49(3),189 203.Beijing,China. Hallinger.(2018).Bringingcontextoutoftheshadowsofleadership.EducationalManagementAdministration&Leadership,46(1),5 24.London,UK. Hoy,&Miskel.(2013).Educationaladministration:Theory,research,andpractice(9thed.).McGraw-Hill.NewYork,USA. Hoy,&Miskel.(2019).Educationaladministration:Theory,research,andpractice(10thed.).McGraw-Hill.NewYork,USA. Huberman.(1989).Theprofessionallifecycleofteachers.TeachersCollegeRecord,91(1),31 57.NewYork,USA. Kanjanawasee.(2016).SchooladministrationandteacherprofessionaldevelopmentinThailand.AsianEducationalResearchJournal,5(2),44 58.Bangkok,Thailand. Krejcie,&Morgan.(1970).Determiningsamplesizeforresearchactivities.EducationalandPsychologicalMeasurement,30(3),607 610.London,UK. LiZhengtao.(2018).Teacherprofessionaldevelopmentfromtheschoolpracticeperspective.JournalofEducationalResearchinChina,39(4),72 78.Beijing,China. OECD.(2015).Teachers professionallearninginTALIS.OECDPublishing.Paris,France. OECD.(2019).TALIS2018results:Teachersandschoolleadersaslivelonglearners.OECDPublishing.Paris,France. Schleicher.(2020).Worldclass:Howtobuilda21st-centuryschoolsystem.OECDPublishing.Paris,France. Skaalvik,&Skaalvik.(2017).Motivationandburnoutinteachers:Theroleofschoolcontext.TeachingandTeacherEducation,67,152 160.London,UK. WangBenlu.(2019).Schoolsupportandteacherprofessionallearning:Anempiricalstudy.ChinaEducationalReview,10(2),45 53.Beijing,China. YeLan.(2015).Lifelongprofessionalgrowthofteachers.EducationalScienceResearch,36(6),15 21.Beijing,China. ZhongBinglin.(2017).Institutionalsupportandteacherprofessionaldevelopment.EducationalDevelopmentResearch,37(9),23 29.Beijing,China. *3120##!2#2#(6)2A+H 24.(2018).Teacherprofessionaldevelopmentpolicyinbasiceducation.OfficeoftheEducationCouncil.Bangkok,Thailand.     PAGE 4 [PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT2] 2#*H@*#4!2#12'4 2 5#9CB#@#5"!1"!(6)2C# 2 8 !%5K+%4: 1. 2#12'2!#9I2'4 2 5 2. 1)0A%02#4142'4 2 5 3. 1(4A%0-1%1)L2'4 2 5 4. 2#*1*8@ 4-L#A%0@ 4*21 I-!9%1H'D-9I-A*-2!: 1. 2-B#@#5" 1) B#@#5"2@%G (#9 50 +#7-I-"'H2) 2) B#@#5"2%2 (#9 51 100 ) 3) B#@#5"2C+ H (#9 101 6ID) 2. #0"0@'%22#4142-#9 1) 1 15 5 2) 15 56ID "$&0 *rt^`ͻͻͻͻͻͻͻͻͻͻ͘&h"S<hDQ5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ h"S<CJ OJQJ^JaJ )hDQhDQ5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ #hDQhDQCJ OJQJ^JaJ  hDQhDQCJ OJQJ^JaJ hDQCJ OJQJ^JaJ &hDQhDQ5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ -&t`HJBx8:b   WD`gd"S< gdDQFHJbr~~@BZvx68:R` b j r        ȷȷ hDQh"S<CJ OJQJ^JaJ hDQCJ OJQJ^JaJ #hDQhDQCJ OJQJ^JaJ  hDQhDQCJ OJQJ^JaJ h"S<CJ OJQJ^JaJ &h"S<hDQ5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ )h"S<hDQ5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ 4024R(*BR^! !"!"###%%&j)l)**+,T,2-p-.N.P.///ϻ h"S<5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ )h"S<hDQ5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ &h"S<hDQ5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ h"S<CJ OJQJ^JaJ #hDQhDQCJ OJQJ^JaJ  hDQhDQCJ OJQJ^JaJ 224* !#%l)P.// 0"000`47>:<,?AA6B8B gd"S< gdDQ WD`gd"S<//0 0"0,000002^4`4x46777:<:>:F:N:j:<<>*?,?AAAAB4B6B8BTBEEEEEFHHHH>HJɵɏ}}}}}}}}}}}ɵɏ}}}}}}#h"S<h"S<CJ OJQJ^JaJ  h"S<h"S<CJ OJQJ^JaJ )h"S<h"S<5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ &h"S<h"S<5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ h"S<CJ OJQJ^JaJ )h[0h"S<5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ &h[0h"S<5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ 18BEHJF^DFltڐܐ6FRFHhp 8@\24npԦ֦dfʭ̭έحʸʸʸʸʸʸʸʸʸʸʸʸʸʸʸʸʸʸʸʸʸ죣)h"S<h"S<5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ #h"S<h"S<CJ OJQJ^JaJ  h"S<h"S<CJ OJQJ^JaJ h"S<5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ &h"S<h"S<5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ @̭έ ְ`fZ&0^pRJL gd"S< WD`gd gdDQ WD`gd"S< 8@l԰ְ $,LƳܳƵ^`dfXZ$&fh.08\^npPR޷(h"S<5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ nHtH#h"S<h"S<CJ OJQJ^JaJ  h"S<h"S<CJ OJQJ^JaJ h"S<5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ ?HJL~lz,z|XZz"*FfhXf4602躤(h"S<h"S<CJ OJQJ^JaJ nHtH+h"S<h"S<CJ OJQJ^JaJ nHtH(h"S<5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ nHtH1h"S<h"S<5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ nHtH.h"S<h"S<5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ nHtH8|Zh62^`4v "$& WD`gd(N gd L WD`gd"S<2\^`b`px|24:tv|wwwdwdwdwdwPP&h|$5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o(%h(NCJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH h(Nh(NCJ OJQJ^JaJ #h(Nh(NCJ OJQJ^JaJ )h}*h}*5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ #hd5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ #h}*5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o(+h"S<h"S<CJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH+h"S<h"S<CJ OJQJ^JaJ nHtH "$&(*,.02468:<>@V\iT@&h|$h|$5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ )h|$h|$5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ +h(N5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ nHo(tH(hd5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ nHtH hd5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ 4jhd5CJ OJQJU\^JaJ mHnHu h|$5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ 7jhd5CJ OJQJU\^JaJ mHnHo(u#h|$5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o(&(*,02468:<>@< gddPL$a$ gd|$$a$gd|$ $ a$gd(N gd L\^̺o[I5'h|$CJ OJQJ^JaJ &h|$5CJ$OJQJ\^JaJ$o(#h|$5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ &h|$5CJ(OJQJ\^JaJ(o(,hS-h|$5CJ(OJQJ\^JaJ(o( h|$5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ h}*5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ #h}*5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o(#h|$5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o( h|$h}*CJ OJQJ^JaJ #h|$h|$CJ OJQJ^JaJ  h|$h|$CJ OJQJ^JaJ  :<Bvx~$bdf4<hȷȷȷȷȷȷȷȷteVȷh|$CJ OJQJ^JaJ o(hB4KCJ OJQJ^JaJ o(5hB4KhB4K5B*CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o(ph,hwhX.5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o( h|$5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ hdPLhdPLCJ OJQJ^JaJ #hdPLhdPLCJ OJQJ^JaJ %hdPLCJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH#h}*h|$CJ OJQJ^JaJ o(!<xdf"$&:^v $$Ifa$gd|$ $$Ifa$gdpV(gd|$ WD`gddPL$ F`a$ gd|$ gd|$ gd|$ gd L gddPLhlx46\^LTR "滛q` h|$h|$CJ OJQJ^JaJ #h|$h|$CJ OJQJ^JaJ )h|$h|$5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ #hdPL5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ #h|$h|$CJ OJQJ^JaJ o(hdPLCJ OJQJ^JaJ %hs.CJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH#hdPLhdPLCJ OJQJ^JaJ  hdPLhdPLCJ OJQJ^JaJ "$&8:\^tv|~ &,068:Ǵǡǡǡǡǡxeeeeeeeeee%hpV(CJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH'h|$hpV(CJ OJPJQJ^JaJ hpV(CJ OJQJ^JaJ hpV(^J$h|$hpV(CJ OJPJQJ^JaJ $hdPLhpV(CJ OJPJQJ^JaJ 'hpV(hpV(CJ OJPJQJ^JaJ "hpV(CJ OJQJ^JaJ nHtH#h|$h|$CJOJQJ^JaJ#v~ $$Ifa$gd|$' $Ifgd|$kd$$Ifl֞ ]w  t064aytpV( &,068 $$Ifa$gd|$8:' $Ifgd|$kd$$Ifl֞ ]w  t064aytpV( $$Ifa$gd|$' $Ifgd|$kdZ$$Ifl֞ ]w  t064aytpV( &*024PRT~ &*024vzǴڴǴǴ|-h|$hpV(5CJ OJPJQJ\^JaJ hpV(CJ OJQJ^JaJ $h|$hpV(CJ OJPJQJ^JaJ %hpV(CJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH$hdPLhpV(CJ OJPJQJ^JaJ %hs.CJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH$hpV(hpV(CJ OJPJQJ^JaJ * &*02 $$Ifa$gd|$24' $Ifgd|$kd$$Ifl֞ ]w  t064aytpV( $$Ifa$gd|$' $Ifgd|$kd$$Ifl֞ ]w  t064aytpV( &*02 $$Ifa$gd|$24v' $Ifgd|$kda$$Ifl֞ ]w  t064aytpV(vz $$Ifa$gd|$' $$Ifa$gd|$kd$$Ifl֞ ]w  t064aytpV(6DFHLXZ\ƵmWBmWBmWB(h%h%CJ OJQJ^JaJ nHtH+h%h%CJ OJQJ^JaJ nHtH"h%CJ OJQJ^JaJ nHtH%h%CJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH#h%h%CJ OJQJ^JaJ  h%h%CJ OJQJ^JaJ h|$h|$CJ OJQJ^JaJ hpV(CJ OJQJ^JaJ +hpV(5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ nHo(tH*h|$hpV(5CJ OJPJQJ\^JaJ  $$Ifa$gd|$'"gd|$kd$$Ifl֞ ]w  t064aytpV(H\,.vBlnx WD`gd gd% FdWD`gds. gd|$ @WDd`@gd%*,.tvt԰zl^L;L;LL; hs.hs.CJ OJQJ^JaJ #hs.hs.CJ OJQJ^JaJ hs.CJ OJQJ^JaJ hWCJ OJQJ^JaJ ,hwhg5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o( h|$h%CJ OJQJ^JaJ h|$CJ OJQJ^JaJ h%h%CJ OJQJ^JaJ %h%CJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH(h%h%CJ OJQJ^JaJ nHtH+h%h%CJ OJQJ^JaJ nHtH@Bjln8:vx| d |  ۻp_p_pp__p_p_p_ hhCJ OJQJ^JaJ #hhCJ OJQJ^JaJ %hCJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH h|$5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ )h|$h|$5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ h|$CJ OJQJ^JaJ #hs.hs.CJ OJQJ^JaJ  hs.hs.CJ OJQJ^JaJ %hs.CJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH%        B D H ` v b d h        v x z | X \  "B\^`shs.CJ OJQJ^JaJ "hs.CJ OJQJ^JaJ nHtH&h|$5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o( h5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ h|$5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ %hCJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH hhCJ OJQJ^JaJ #hhCJ OJQJ^JaJ + D d  x ^`^ WD`gd| gd|$ eWD^e`gds. WD,`gds. WD`gds. gds. WD`gd48\^bdlXϼϼϼ򫔀nn`On h|h|CJ OJQJ^JaJ h|CJ OJQJ^JaJ #h|h|CJ OJQJ^JaJ &hwhBJ25CJ OJQJ\^JaJ ,hwhBJ25CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o( hs.5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ %hs.CJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH hs.hs.CJ OJQJ^JaJ #hs.hs.CJ OJQJ^JaJ h|$CJ OJQJ^JaJ XZ`,.4nprtz|v<>@tfhzCJ OJQJ^JaJ hWCJ OJQJ^JaJ ,hwh_u5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o(,hwh}5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o( h|$5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ h|$CJ OJQJ^JaJ #h|h|CJ OJQJ^JaJ  h|h|CJ OJQJ^JaJ h|CJ OJQJ^JaJ (Z.pt|@B B      $ a$gd|$ gd|  WD` gd| WD`gd| gd L WD`gd|@BD   6 B F r         !!!o^L#hz5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o( hW5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ ,hChC5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o(#h|5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ +hW5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ nHo(tH%h|CJ OJQJ^JaJ nHo(tH h|h|CJ OJQJ^JaJ #h|h|CJ OJQJ^JaJ hWCJ OJQJ^JaJ h|CJ OJQJ^JaJ  !!"""#p$.%&'(()v*+,-X."//012344 0^`0gdGT 0^`0gd L $ a$gd|$!!""""#p$.%&&'(()*v*+,-.X."//0122344444444444444444455555 5߻hh|$h0JmHnHujh0JU h|$0Jjh|$0JUhZwjhZwU#h L5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o(#hGThGTCJ OJQJ^JaJ  hGThGTCJ OJQJ^JaJ h|$CJ OJQJ^JaJ o(3444444444555 5 555555555T5V5X5Z55gd(N$a$&`#$ 5 5555555555 5J5L5N5P5R5T5V5X5Z5555&6(6,6f6h6l66666666787<7\7^7b777777777780868J8L8P888888888888ۼ#h L5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ o(hdh(N h(NhEZ h~o(h~jh~Uh~mHnHsHtHhC5(6h666687^777L8888888 0^`0gdGT HWD,`Hgd(Ngd(N 0WD`0gd(N5 01}:p|$. A!p"#p$%v) ?0P1}:p~. A!p"#p$%v) Dp?0P1}:p. A!p"#p$%v) Dp5 01}:p|$. A!p"#p$%v) 5 01}:p|$. A!p"#p$%v) $$Ifg!vh#v #v#v#vu#vM#v#vu:V l t06,54 ytpV($$Ifg!vh#v #v#v#vu#vM#v#vu:V l t06,54 ytpV($$Ifg!vh#v #v#v#vu#vM#v#vu:V l t06,54 ytpV($$Ifg!vh#v #v#v#vu#vM#v#vu:V l t06,54 ytpV($$Ifg!vh#v #v#v#vu#vM#v#vu:V l t06,54 ytpV($$Ifg!vh#v #v#v#vu#vM#v#vu:V l t06,54 ytpV($$Ifg!vh#v #v#v#vu#vM#v#vu:V l t06,54 ytpV($$Ifg!vh#v #v#v#vu#vM#v#vu:V l t06,54 ytpV("x002 0@P`p2( 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p8XV~ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@66666$OJPJQJ^J_HmH nHsH tH<`< NckeCJ^J_HaJmH sH tH BB h 1$$@&a$5CJ$\^J aJ$66 h 2$@& CJ ^J aJ RR h 3$$R@&]Ra$5CJ$OJQJ\^JaJ$DD h 4$@&5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ FF h 5$@&]CJ OJQJ^JaJ RR h 6$$@&]a$5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ NN h 7$$@&a$5CJ OJQJ\^JaJ $A`$ ؞k=W[SOFi@F nfh=}sVm,?/ݻg_;G,q7^=C$n3FWZ2sy#t{ eXS`ED1ΰ wcut8+G$XEki;4$)e#vl0Xewu|"n !1]ԗ(lB2lx5Oǘa!|2k9>u6.Krӹp-Aiχm,CQ1o3gʦ! ڔFs/bos@R O‰7:V[St"zc{ dM {ȍUaL-"mM=K<OӼ^mhssΡ ! Bx+@S%)`Yu]ZFfԻ@[f̣>ԙOPڔ9mcO\{ |Te6pp1GZ&L~FdLPCP)E:A entEfԩK%SY$:_h޶n@*^ss56^p!w޻#Emy2zuk sj0mn)4iExMW_PK! ѐ'theme/theme/_rels/themeManager.xml.relsM 0wooӺ&݈Э5 6?$Q ,.aic21h:qm@RN;d`o7gK(M&$R(.1r'JЊT8V"AȻHu}|$b{P8g/]QAsم(#L[PK-![Content_Types].xmlPK-!֧6 0_rels/.relsPK-!kytheme/theme/themeManager.xmlPK-!vZ)O theme/theme/theme1.xmlPK-! ѐ'Y theme/theme/_rels/themeManager.xml.relsPK]T  hEG'\ hss7sxss !####AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAD <K,MrR*[`|jou~x}@h2֬ޮt6@":~V/Jit2\h" X@! 58 LZ4hr~ƑЬ46"M&8Bṱ&<v822v 458 $:<D!!@ @ (  P   "? P   "? J  # "?B  Z$"1'@ 7H-!H-# 13",?PK!8[Content_Types].xmlAN0EH%N@%邴K@`dOdlyLhoDX3'AL:*/@X*eRp208J妾)G,R}Q)=HiҺ0BL):T뢸WQDY;d]6O&8* VCLj"󃒝 yJ.;[wIC_ :{IOA !>Ø4 p;fɑ3׶Vc.ӵn(&poPK!8! _rels/.relsj0 }qN/k؊c[F232zQLZ%R6zPT]( LJ[ۑ̱j,Z˫fLV:*f"N.]m@= 7LuP[i?T;GI4Ew=}3b9`5YCƵkρؖ9#ۄo~e?zrPK!|Mhdrs/e2oDoc.xmlSn1}G,Mi*>4%1;mwv.g̮މ=f1 j6چ {x^ *4pG$y~j5qNc  RRuF@0pgu:ub)GDݜrAUCX$s+ֳ[eHUO4?Xx/=Cm_Pު)2Sw\ [/,Lr>6>^ݗ_[YPK!}drs/downrev.xmlLN0DHHܨSZ(ĩ$$ p8mgѬ޼-ň!v,ƛZoW94{B_a[0~W P,PHNDžtZizye7x-6B܇' *uy1݂H8cguiOd#Iz|\fY| PK-!8[Content_Types].xmlPK-!8! /_rels/.relsPK-!|Mh.drs/e2oDoc.xmlPK-!} drs/downrev.xmlPKB S  ? H0(  BBB h+z +tL.tBV8t++t _Hlk91246059 _Hlk191111522 OLE_LINK29 OLE_LINK30!),D,D h":DD h'KjkF#25>EMP\^fw0EHJSdp!!# !! ) }   ORRW(113v!x!z!}!!!!!!!{"""" ##x#z###$#$5$B$U$l$$$$%%8%;%T%W%s%v%%%%%%%%&&&&&&&&&''M'm'''''c(d(j)l)r)u)})))))))) **(*+*R*U*r*u*******++@+D+o+s+++++++,,R,S,p,x,,,,,----G-I-v-x-----..k.n.|........////J/L/y/{/////00(0+0R0V000%1@1c1g1j1m111111111112 2 22&2*232722222223353:3a3f3333333O4T4444444u5y555h6k66666666657B7D7777788@8B8J8f8l8888}99999:::::::::;;:;<;R;V;e;l;;;;;;;<<<<#<%<<<<<<<<<= =/=4=G=i=??'?B?Q@T@r@@AAAABBB CCCCDDDEEEEEEFFFGGGGGHHHHJ!J+J4J4L7L_LfLrLvLvNyNNNNNPPTPQQQQQ%R0R1R8R9RfRhRkRrRRRRRS S6S=SoSpSrSsSSSSSSST T9T@TWT]TTTTTTTTT!U)UTU`UUUUUUUV V VVDVLVMVRVVVVVVV2W@WAWEWhWvWwW|WWWWWXXDXPXXY=YBYYYYYYY&Z0Z]Z`ZrZuZZZ[,[P[Z[][`[[[[[[[\ \@\C\t\\\\\\\\\\H]K]]]]]]^+^.^k^n^^^^^^^^^$_%_,_4_Z_]_______<`B```````````)a1aaaaa+b,b1b7brbub|bbbbbb>cAcgchctczccccccc*d0dddddddddMePeeefff"f9f>fffffg"g^gbgggggh hXh_hdhlhhh6ilAlKlNl`lflslvllllllmdmtmmmmmmmnnnnVn[nnnnnnnnno o|oooooo%p(pKpOpRp^pkpqpppppppqqSqVqyqzqqqqqqq!r&rKrQrrrrrss&s(s?KLQTɧ̧ FMRVqt  $'*x{ĩȩfgqrw{CH ¬$.3:?CʭͭNOWX[\dejn֮ޮ+/X`|}үۯR\Ӱٰ w}ϱұѲڲ).qt PS 6:AIRZehvyŶ  25[^{ HKùŹʹй 03jm 9@pW\.=Whpvw{KYagHUX]ao<IQW ,9]c+A`{y=AotxEH%8JKTU]cz04;Co},PQYZ^fnr,6Cw       & ( ,   4<bpt(9AGKW#+37CKQ7DHV_j  """"""$$'$-$1$9$:$>$F$N$v%%%%z&&&&''(())**++++&,+,,,7-D-V-[---P.U. ////0000L1N1g1m111 22+3>34455664898=8K8[9h999n:o:w:x:|:::w;x;;;;;t<x<==>>@@F@VAYAqAsAAAAAABB!B%BABEBbBfBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCD D*D.DEDIDcDgDDDDDDDDDDDBEFE\E^EdEEElFwF|FFFFGG1G4GQGiGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGHHHrIuIIIIJJNJVJJJJJK#K=K?KKKKKLLLL M"MHMJMmMoMMMMMMMNNDNFNcNgNOOOO1PZPfPkPoPtPPPPPPPPPYQ\QhQtQQQQQQQTRWRRRRRSSVSXSYS[SkSnSSSBTDTTTTTTTZU^UUUVVVV#V%VVVVV>WBWX%X^XjXXXXX Y+YeYiY ZZkZzZZZ%['[,[/[F[J[[[[[[[[[[[\\\'\(\*\4\eefffffffff6f7fTfUffffffffg"g$gCgGgVgZgpgsgggggggggggggghhh h+kF23BE\^j0EHJKde  } ~   OP()v!x!!|"~"""z###$$8%%''''''c(d(j)l))) *S,p,q,..00(0)0R0S000=11142233333O4P44y55666?8@8f8::;<;R;S;e;i;;;;;;;<<<<#<%<<<<<<<<<= =0=4=G=g=??'?@?Q@T@@@AAAABBBCCCCDDDEEEEEEFFFGGGGGHHHHJQPQQQQQQQhRRpSSTTFXYY[ [t\u\\]$_%_<``+b,bgchcddffgg6ikdmemnnKpRpyqzqrsStTtuu w wxx z zz|'~(~`aԃՃ?@:;AB23CEy{hiܑݑBGei9=:@ۚܚIKno¢ĢLfg$.N\|}ѲҲùŹ x]^{=>F01;)  _`  "'(())**++&,',,,V-W---P.Q. ////0N1+3u<==>>@@A@VAYAqAsABBBBBBBBBB CD*DDDD{F|FGGGGGGGGGGGGGGHHHrIuIIIIJJUJVJJJJJ!K#K=K?KKKKK M!MHMIMmMnMMMMMMMNPPXSkSnSSV#V%VV'[G[J[['\5\<\\\\\\\\\] ]]]:];]g]t]]]]]]]]]]]^^)^*^=^?^G^K^^^^^^^__)_+_6_:___________````#`'`B`C`R`f`n`o```````````Va_aiataaaaaaabbjbtb~bbbbbbbbbbbb*c+c7c9cEcIcUcfcccccc ddd$d(dUdddddddddeeeiese}eeffffffffffTfUff$gCgh h333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333E^z##S,q,2333;%<<<QQ:TXTB"BBBcBBBBBDDGHHEHtHHHHHH3IIXSnS'[G[[&\effffffffff6fRfTfUfghh h55555555666666666666666666666666666>8?8?8@8@8h899:;:;<;#<%<=BB5\5\7\ffffffffffff,fTfUf#g$gh h.nnff~nNT? LRea/P/K?0MzQO.J܀3Ldd" %h"vcp0 : JC*&Ά^ "xng]% P( .F+M)nR,F=nL0xnx_6AnO<6"t8@.E;}=ts?xn@RRDn.IEn.#FPIHP$XESH;18z-T4@Y@q:[Ai]jcg x`"a:h?BLh1o_sYttq @0wPNzfF }6 ^`o(^`o(.p^p`o(..^`o(... ^`o( .... ^`o( ..... ^`o( ...... ^`o(....... ^`o(........ ff^f`_Ho(.^`o()H^`H)H^`H.` H^` `H. H^ `H) H^ `H.H^`H.@H^@`H)H^`H.^`o(.H^`H)H^`H.c H^c `H. H^ `H) H^ `H.H^`H.CH^C`H)H^`H. ff^f`_Ho(. hh^h`_Ho(.^`o() H^`HhH) H^`HhH. HH^H`HhH.  H^ `HhH)  H^ `HhH. p H^p `HhH. (H^(`HhH) H^`HhH.8^8`5o(. ^`hH.  L^ `LhH.  ^ `hH. x^x`hH. HL^H`LhH. ^`hH. ^`hH. L^`LhH.^`OJPJQJ^J)H^`H) H^ `H.\ H^\ `H. H^ `H)H^`H.H^`H.<H^<`H)H^`H.^`o(. ^`hH. pL^p`LhH. @ ^@ `hH. ^`hH. L^`LhH. ^`hH. ^`hH. PL^P`LhH.^`OJ PJQJ ^Jo(   ^ `OJQJo(o   ^ `OJQJo( xx^x`OJQJo( HH^H`OJQJo(o ^`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(o ^`OJQJo(^`o() H^ `H) H^ `H.t H^t `H.,H^,`H)H^`H.H^`H.TH^T`H) H^ `H.^`OJPJQJ^J)H^`H) H^ `H.\ H^\ `H. H^ `H)H^`H.H^`H.<H^<`H)H^`H. hh^h`_Ho(.^`o(. ^`hH. pL^p`LhH. @ ^@ `hH. ^`hH. L^`LhH. ^`hH. ^`hH. PL^P`LhH.  pp^p`_Ho(.^`OJ PJQJ ^Jo( ^ `OJQJ^Jo(hHo ^ `OJQJo(hHx^x`OJQJo(hHH^H`OJQJ^Jo(hHo^`OJQJo(hH^`OJQJo(hH^`OJQJ^Jo(hHo^`OJQJo(hH hh^h`_Ho(. ^`hH.^`o(. 0^ `0o(.. 0^ `0o(... X^X`o( .... F^F`o( ..... `^``o( ...... `^``o(....... ^`o(........^`o(. ^`hH. pL^p`LhH. @ ^@ `hH. ^`hH. L^`LhH. ^`hH. ^`hH. PL^P`LhH.  ff^f`_Ho(.h^h`o() pH^p`HhH) (H^(`HhH. H^`HhH. H^`HhH) P H^P `HhH.  H^ `HhH.  H^ `HhH) xH^x`HhH.h^h`o() pH^p`HhH) (H^(`HhH. H^`HhH. H^`HhH) P H^P `HhH.  H^ `HhH.  H^ `HhH) xH^x`HhH. hh^h`_Ho(.^`o()H^`H)H^`H.` H^` `H. H^ `H) H^ `H.H^`H.@H^@`H)H^`H.8^8`o(. ^`hH.  L^ `LhH.  ^ `hH. x^x`hH. HL^H`LhH. ^`hH. ^`hH. L^`LhH.^`o(.8^8`o(.0^`0o(..p0^p`0o(... @ ^@ `o( ....  ^ `o( ..... x`^x``o( ...... `^``o(....... ^`o(........ ^`5\o(. 8^8`5\o(.0^`0o(..p0^p`0o(... @ ^@ `o( ....  ^ `o( ..... x`^x``o( ...... `^``o(....... ^`o(........ hh^h`_Ho(. hh^h`_Ho(.^`o(. ^`hH. pL^p`LhH. @ ^@ `hH. ^`hH. L^`LhH. ^`hH. ^`hH. PL^P`LhH. ^`o(hH. ^`hH. pL^p`LhH. @ ^@ `hH. ^`hH. L^`LhH. ^`hH. ^`hH. PL^P`LhH.  88^8`_Ho(.$^`5\_Ho(.$ p0p^p`0_Ho(..$  0 ^ `0_Ho(...$   ^ `_Ho( ....$ ^`_Ho( .....$ xx^x`_Ho( ......$  H`H^H``_Ho(.......$  `^``_Ho(........h^h`o() pH^p`HhH) (H^(`HhH. H^`HhH. H^`HhH) P H^P `HhH.  H^ `HhH.  H^ `HhH) xH^x`HhH.h^h`o() pH^p`HhH) ( H^( `HhH.  H^ `HhH.  H^ `HhH) PH^P`HhH. H^`HhH. H^`HhH) xH^x`HhH. hh^h`_Ho(. hh^h`_Ho(.f^`fo()H^`H)H^`H.` H^` `H. H^ `H) H^ `H.H^`H.@H^@`H)H^`H. hh^h`_Ho(.^`OJPJQJ^J H^`H)H^`H.` H^` `H. H^ `H) H^ `H.H^`H.@H^@`H)H^`H. hh^h`_Ho(.L^L`o() T H^T `HhH)  H^ `HhH.  H^ `HhH. |H^|`HhH) 4H^4`HhH. H^`HhH. H^`HhH) \H^\`HhH.  hh^h`_Ho(.  ^`_Ho(.  ^`_Ho(..^IHP#FPLh.E;YtMzF+M) x`"aY@0w~nK?x_6PNzg]F }cpP(nL0.IE$XES%h "s?@RRD8z-TnR,fea/ }=1o:hC*Ldt:[n :t8QOnO<6i]..x        lh                2        T        TȤ        T                         ?        ĚG        D                          h        X        L        i        Fc        fQ66~ '1U~GTtJW:q>  E x :h6%JN) }Gud^J]K~W!@,A9E$jOqbUq}6 A<#p$|$ [% '[{'@(pV('h(z()K]-s.c0O0C1#2BJ28O4Rr5z5f7/k7?:DH:y:p;"S<+~<=>>04CoEHJIrOI J+KB4K5[K-0LdPLZ0MN(NRNfO7ODQTnTUVVV V WU:W7HWIYNZK-[ \ \__`J3cCckcocwwcBd?bdgfgCo[033f)KMzz~jTVs{C v(AZ1>(I6gNs.{aC"q]]N0SyNy2(S EZ\e LZX^ WovY6<5V} 'ff@%&89;CDG h000R0T0x0z0~0000N0Z0UnknownG.[x Times New Roman5Symbol3. .[x ArialC.TH SarabunPSK7..{$ Calibri;([SOSimSun?Angsana New=. Cordia New?|8I{~DengXian=AngsanaUPC75 Courier5. .[`)Tahoma9,|8I{~ Light?Wingdings 2?= .Cx Courier New;WingdingsA$BCambria Math"qhG gG<H)8 <H)8 !pp20cc 2Q@P?jEZ2!xxd7 14'4"2%1"jongkola53109.                           ! " # $ % & ' ( ) * + , - Oh+'0   @ L X dpx,บัณฑิตวิทยาลัยjongkolNormala5310915Microsoft Office Word@:@P$@@E8<H) ՜.+,0| hp  .Kanchanaburi c +บัณฑิตวิทยาลัย+บัณฑิตวิทยาลัย Titleชื่อเรื่อง  !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~      !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~      !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABDEFGHIJLMNOPQRYRoot Entry F E[Data 1TablefWordDocument'SummaryInformation(CDocumentSummaryInformation8KCompObjn  FMicrosoft Word 97-2003 ĵ MSWordDocWord.Document.89q